Friday’s Supreme Court decision found that the general national standards are within federal jurisdiction and can be binding on the provincial government when the provinces choose to deliver such services to Indigenous people. The effects on provincial public servants were held to be incidental in this particular case but the constitutional principle the CCF sought to preserve remains intact.
“The bottom line is that the Court has not said that a province can be compelled to administer federal laws or programs,” said Jesse Hartery, who argued the case in the Supreme Court on behalf of the CCF. “The Court has said that a province can be required to comply with these general standards if it is choosing to provide these services, like all other service providers.”
CCF Executive Director Joanna Baron said she believes the CCF’s arguments appeared to make a difference and thanked Jesse Hartery, Simon Bouthillier and Allison Spiegel for their work on the intervention.
“We intervened on a narrow point of law in this case to preserve the constitutional division of powers and we are pleased that the court appears to have done so,” she added
Members of the public interested in supporting the legal fees associated with this case can make a tax deductible charitable donation at theCCF.ca/donate/
For further information, contact:
Joanna Baron
Executive Director
Canadian Constitution Foundation
1-888-695-9105 x. 101
jbaron@theccf.ca