Burning of the The Great Library of Alexandria
Perhaps the most famous historical instance was the partial and then final burning of the celebrated library in Alexandria over three separate occasions: 48 BC (by Julius Caesar, according to Plutarch); 391-415 AD (often attributed to Christian rioters); and 640 AD by a Muslim army. As Edward Gibbon recounts, upon learning of a great library containing all the knowledge of the world, the conquering general supposedly asked the Caliph for instructions regarding the Library’s holdings. He replied, “They will either contradict the Koran, in which case they are heresy, or they will agree with it, so they are superfluous.” In any case, though remnants survived, the Library essentially ceased to exist.
The destruction of the great library in Baghdad in 1258 was not by fire but by water, which amounts to the same thing. Legend has it that when the Mongols laid siege to Baghdad, the library’s entire collection of manuscripts and books was thrown into the Tigris. The river is said to have run black with ink for seven days.
A famed European instance has given us the phrase “bonfire of the vanities” — of which there were many such cremations over the years — instigated by the Dominican friar Girolamo Savonarola in Florence in 1497. He sponsored several of these “bonfires of the vanities” where classical books and works of art were burned, including manuscripts, sculptures, paintings, musical instruments, gaming tables, nude statues, harmless trinkets, beauty products, and anything considered a work of art.
Savonarola, writes Richard Cavendish in History Today (v. 48, Issue 5, May 1988), “grimly disapproved of jokes and frivolity, of poetry and inns, of sex (especially the homosexual variety), of gambling, of fine clothes and jewellery and luxury of every sort. He denounced the works of Boccaccio, nude paintings, pictures of pagan deities and the whole humanistic culture of the Italian Renaissance. He called for laws against vice and laxity. The friar also disapproved of profiteering financiers and businessmen. He put an end to the carnivals and festivals the Florentines traditionally enjoyed, substituting religious festivals instead, and employed street urchins as a junior gestapo to sniff out luxurious and suspect items.” (One thinks of the recent looting spree in Philadelphia of high-end commercial establishments, whose perpetrators NBC Philadelphia dismissed as “mostly consisting of juveniles.” Though, of course, the motives of the junior gestapo and the Philly juveniles vary.)