The commissioners, who were charged with finding the “truth” were instead spreading misinformation
It will fall to future historians and other experts to analyze the TRC findings, in light of the fact that all three commissioners appeared to believe that the government officials, priests, teachers and others working in the residential schools — many of them themselves indigenous — were engaged in an absolutely horrible conspiracy to kill and secretly bury thousands of indigenous children.
But one thing is certain: The commissioners believed Annett’s stories.
That became completely clear immediately after the Kamloops announcement. Commissioner Wilson alleged that “thousands of indigenous children were ripped out of their mothers’ arms, never to be seen again”. Sinclair increased the “thousands” to “25,000.
The commissioners, who were charged with finding the “truth” were instead spreading misinformation.
So, the 2021 Kamloops claim, with all the copycat claims, and church burnings that followed really aren’t that surprising, given the fact that Canadians had been told by the TRC for a decade to believe these Annett anti-Catholic memes. Nor is it that surprising that impressionable young journalists, or even an impressionable prime minister, should react as they did — blind acceptance, with no questions asked.
The result for the country is an unmitigated disaster. The indigenous community now believes a false narrative. That same false narrative is being taught in Canadian schools as fact. All of our major institutions are pretending to believe – for now – claims they know are not true.
On May 27, 2021, all of our major institutions failed. Our prime minister behaved more like an emotional schoolboy than a leader, our legacy media failed to ask even the most basic questions, our RCMP hid in their detachment offices, and senior indigenous leaders made reckless claims.
But it was the institution charged with the responsibility to find the “truth” — the TRC — that was ultimately responsible for this national tragedy. The commissioners bought into Kevin Annett’s conspiracy theory. All Canadians — but particularly indigenous Canadians — will pay the price for generations.
Brian Giesbrecht, retired judge, is a Senior Fellow at the Frontier Centre for Public Policy