So why all the fuss about CO2 and all the claims that it is causing climate change? That brings us to climate models. It turns out that nearly all the "evidence" for CO2 caused climate change comes from mathematical systems implemented in climate models. Did I hear someone mention ‘mathemagic’ again?
Don't misunderstand. As someone who has written and used computer models for over fifty years, I can attest to their value when they are properly designed, implemented, and used within their limitations. Unfortunately, in most cases, none of these conditions are met in climate models. A model is only as good as the assumptions used in its construction, and many of the assumptions used in making climate models don't hold up well.
Take for example, the basic assumption of the relationship between CO2 concentration and temperature. Almost all models use a mathematical formula that says increases in CO2 concentration will result in higher temperatures. Models incorporating this formula are then run to "prove" that increases in CO2 concentration will result in higher global temperatures. Does anyone notice a problem here?
This formula was introduced and its use endorsed by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) of the UN. You know, the same people who are saying that we all need to cut back on fossil fuel consumption and CO2 release to save the planet. To be fair, there is good laboratory data to show that in particular conditions, the relationship holds true. But to simply build it into a model is to neglect the complex dynamics of energy exchange, absorption and release of energy that exist in a real atmosphere.
A second and related issue is how most computer models treat the effects of clouds. The IPCC —remember them?—considers that the only effects of clouds are in their reflection of sunlight back to space (albedo effects) which reduce the amount of solar heat that reaches the Earth's surface, and the ability of clouds to reflect heat energy back to the surface. The entire complex dynamics of heat transport coupled with phase changes as water vapor condenses to liquid water and sometimes to ice is completely ignored.
One of my fellow scientists and I have been working on an analysis that shows how clouds can transport great quantities of heat from the surface of the Earth, through the low-lying layer of CO2, upwards to high altitudes where that heat can be radiated out to space. The quantities of heat involved, as well as the mechanisms of transport work to maintain the Earth temperature within a fairly narrow range in much the same way that a furnace and air conditioning act to keep a comfortable temperature in a building. We expect to publish a professional paper on this research later this summer.
It is worth noting that most of the "evidence" supporting the idea of a Climate Crisis comes from projections based on computer models. As we see, these models have several important flaws, only two of which we've described here. The contrary evidence, on the other hand, largely comes from hard data obtained from real-world investigations, such as the ice core data described.
This hard evidence largely contradicts the model supported ideas that human sourced CO2 is causing the global temperatures to rise and climate to change. Instead, it tells a story of natural cycles of change over timescales ranging from decades to centuries to thousands to millions of years, and humans are just along for the ride.
Stage magic is fun and entertaining, but makes no statement about the real world other than to point out how easily humans can be misled about what is happening. The damage happens when we allow magic to infiltrate our science and our politics and mislead us about the world. It is time to reveal the ‘mathemagic’ that is deceiving us in our understanding of climate change. The magic show has gone on too long and is too expensive to be considered entertaining. Reality must trump illusion. Time to draw the curtain and move on.