
The political motives behind sanctuary city "generosity"
The mayors of Chicago and Los Angeles have so far both defied attempts by the Trump administration's Justice Department to uphold the nation's immigration laws

The Political Motive
The threat of the loss of federal funds would seem like an incentive for cities to comply with ICE, but the Byrne JAG award which provides federal funds to law enforcement, accounts for only "three-hundredths of 1 percent" of Chicago's budget--hardly enough to warrant the legal costs to go to court against the federal government. As John Byrne points out in the Chicago Tribune, this presents an opportunity for Emanuel to shore up support among Chicago Hispanics who view the Trump administration with skepticism, as well as bolster his own standing among big city mayors. Emanuel is not too popular in Chicago. His disapproval ratings in May 2016 were 62 percent among Chicago residents overall, and 70 percent among the city's black population. Many of Chicago's minority residents view Emanuel as "the big shot's mayor," representing "the elites downtown" and not their interests. Furthermore, Chicago's failing public schools, crippling violence, and occasional police brutality have not helped Emanuel with this demographic. Thus faced with his own unpopularity, Emanuel has opted to take the fight over a minor law enforcement grant to the Donald Trump administration in the hopes that it will improve his standing both with Democratic elites and his minority constituents.The Monetary Motive
Los Angeles--another city that refuses to cooperate with ICE--gave $1.3 billion in welfare to illegal immigrants in 2015 and 2016 as reported recently by Fox News, which obtained the data from the Los Angeles County Department of Public Social Services. Los Angeles County, which has the largest concentration of illegal immigrants of any county in the U.S., allows them to receive welfare and food stamps. In fact, illegal immigrants there receive nearly a quarter of every dollar spent by the county on its residents in need. Los Angeles' coddling of illegal immigrants is nothing new. As Matthew Vadum notes in CRC's Foundation Watch, in 2008 the Los Angeles City Council voted unanimously to force home improvement stores like Home Depot to build shelters for illegal immigrant day laborers, many of whom are working without legal authorization, in their parking lots. So what makes the governments of the city and county of Los Angeles so generous? Do its leaders simply have bigger, kinder hearts than the rest of the country and the terrible, mean Trump administration trying to uphold the law of the land? As Monica Showalter in American Thinker observes, it's important to look at the financial motives:Conclusion
The mayors of Chicago and Los Angeles have so far both defied attempts by the Trump administration's Justice Department to uphold the nation's immigration laws. According to Emanuel, "Chicago will never relinquish our status as a welcoming city." Garcetti declared that in Los Angeles, "our values are not for sale." But in anti-Trump, Democratic Party strongholds with large, well-paid bureaucracies serving the needs of illegal immigrants, such moral grandstanding is good for both politics and bank accounts. This article first appeared at the website of Capital Research Center, parent organization of Bombthrowers.Read next: The Epstein Narrative’s Manipulated Images and Political Motives to Obscure the Truth
Email Us | Reader Friendly | Comments
Bombthrowers is a blog about politics and the war for the hearts and minds of Americans from a conservative viewpoint.
In line with our name, we do not hold back. We have a take-no-prisoners attitude when it comes to fighting for conservative principles. The Left doesn’t play nice, and that’s why they’ve been winning. It’s time for conservatives to rise up and turn the tide.
We’re not afraid to take on anyone, especially the Washington Establishment—Republican or Democrat.
Bombthrowers is a project supported by the Capital Research Center. Its editor-in-chief is Matthew Vadum.
