Meanwhile, we citizens must struggle to find glimmers of reason in this milieu of thoughtlessness
From a myriad of wreckage items each soldier must choose ten items considered most critical for survival. Individual soldiers then defend their choices before the full group and make revisions based on what is learned from others. From the revised individual lists a group consensus process produces a “consensus solution.”
The consensus solution is then compared with a field-tested “school solution.” With great reliability group consensus solutions outperform individual choices. Lesson learned: decision making benefits from differing opinions freely expressed within an objective decision-making environment.
In contrast to these examples, our national leaders seem fully comfortable within their respective echo chambers where conformance is expected, seeking political advantage masquerades as problem solving, and leadership is too often a matter of seniority rather than competence. Over time, those who keep a glimmer of objectivity (thought criminals in Orwellian terms) are systematically excluded leaving only those willing to surrender independent thought. It is no wonder then that when political delusions are defended with demagoguery and name calling (e.g., Nazi, communist, racist, sexist, and conspiracist) the door to constructive civil discourse is not only closed, but also nailed shut.
Meanwhile, we citizens must struggle to find glimmers of reason in this milieu of thoughtlessness. Our best defense, not surprisingly, is objective thinking. We would be well served to take a cue from the scientific method. Like scientists, we must acknowledge that biases influence every stage of inquiry and left unaddressed will corrupt results. And, like scientists, we are individually responsible for thorough consideration of both confirming and contradictory findings – doing less makes us co-conspirators of those who believe that in the quest for political power truth is optional.
Is Kennedy’s admonition about our tendency to avoid discomforting thought to be our epitaph – or, to paraphrase President Lincoln, will the “…better angels of our nature” arrive in time to save us from ourselves once again?