Words have meaning and weight. Abandoning the field to those who are more aggressive with the language means that defeat and submission will likely follow
Dr. Barton didn’t interpret the story, but simply offered it to his students that day to take from it what they would. The lesson I drew from this was to always stand on a firm grounding in the language: never let the other side seize control in an argument by allowing them to define the terms to their own advantage. Victory may come from the proper definition of terms alone. In fact, victory may only be possible once the terms have been agreed upon. Words have meaning and weight. Abandoning the field to those who are more aggressive with the language means that defeat and submission will likely follow.
It just so happens that there are some recent examples of willful and skillful manipulation of the language. Here are a few.
We hear the term gender batted about every day. For several years, shrill voices in the legacy press and in identity politics circles hammered at this word to get people used to the idea that it meant the same as sex. Once they were able to get everyday people to use it and when companies and hospitals began to use it instead of sex, then the definition began to change. Only certain approved people in the identity politics world were allowed to define gender in the new fashion. In very short order, we went from two sexes to 80+ genders. Once language activists gain control of the definition they win. If there are 80 genders including male and female and pangender and polygender, anyone in opposition to the multigender concept can be dismissed with a sneer. Once the battle to gain acceptance of the term gender to mean sex was won by the activists, there was no resisting the juggernaut of gender activism and the social policies that must follow from it.
To clarify the term, gender is only used correctly when describing the inclinations of nouns. There are three genders: masculine, feminine, and neuter. Masculine nouns and pronouns have masculine endings in Latin and French and German. Nouns and pronouns with masculine endings and masculine characteristics are different from nouns and pronouns with feminine endings and characteristics. Nouns with neither masculine nor feminine endings or characteristics are considered neuter. In German, the first person singular pronouns are der, die, das, that is, masculine, feminine, and neuter.