Trump’s case adds to the long list of judicial travesties on both sides of the border
In the Federal Court of Appeal, Justice David Stratas took the lead for the appellate judges despite having previously represented Bell in a case before the Supreme Court. In 130 words, he justified the exclusion of new evidence by citing a case that had analyzed the purported new evidence in 9,000 words. The Supreme Court declined to hear an appeal despite its importance for the high-tech economy.
Trump’s case adds to the long list of judicial travesties on both sides of the border that the late Christie Blatchford discussed in her book, Life Sentence(15): Stories from four decades of court reporting—Or how I fell out of love with the Canadian justice system (Especially judges). “The judiciary,” she wrote, “is much like the Senate. Like senators they are unelected, unaccountable, entitled, expensive to maintain and remarkably smug.”
If courts in US and Canada don’t deliver credible judging for the rich, like Trump or the Ontario Teachers’ Pension Plan as investors in MediaTube, what hope is there for lesser people? As now exists, although imperfectly, for England and Wales(16), Canadians as well as Americans need outside accountability for lawyers. For judges that need is even more pressing. As US Supreme Court Justice Louis Brandeis(17) once wrote, “If we desire respect for the law, we must first make the law respectable.”
Colin Alexander’s degrees include Politics, Philosophy, and Economics from Oxford. His latest book is Justice on Trial: Jordan Peterson’s case shows we need to fix the broken system.