Crimes increased in the Democrat-controlled city
As a result, crimes increased in the Democrat-controlled city. Gardner, who became the city’s first Black circuit attorney, resigned in May 2023 and was under heavy investigation by Missouri Attorney General Andrew Bailey. When elected, she was part of a movement of progressive leftist prosecutors whose narcissistic beliefs sought diversion to mental health treatment or drug abuse treatment for low-level crimes, pledged to hold police more accountable, and sought to free inmates who were wrongfully convicted
During Gardner's tenure, the Circuit Attorney's Office, which was previously the most active in Missouri in terms of jury trials, experienced a significant decline in the prosecution of criminal cases. This decrease in activity resulted in a near collapse of the city's criminal justice system.
Bailey alleges that due to Gardner's failures, nearly 12,000 criminal cases have been dismissed. Additionally, he claims that over 9,000 cases were thrown out just before trial, which led judges to dismiss more than 2,000 cases because of a lack of evidence and speedy trials for defendants.
In February 2023, a case became the final straw for Bailey. It involved a teenage volleyball player who had come to St. Louis with her team and was hit by a car, resulting in the loss of both her legs. The man who caused the accident had been charged with assault, armed criminal action, and driving without a valid license; despite violating the terms of his bond several dozen times.