Go ahead and enslave us all but tell us after it’s too late. It’s for our own good, right?
In an odd kind of way, it’s exactly the same as the argument behind the Wisconsin Idea, the original basis of Progressivism. Don’t worry about handing over power to control people. It’s going to be experts, scientists, people who only want the best result for the public good that will be looking at these problems and giving us solutions. They won’t be political types, just experts. They’ll be able to look at everything objectively! They’ll weigh all the data and choose the best answer! And anyhow, it’s for your own good.
With accountability, like famous quotes, the name at the end makes all the difference. That name is a big part of the accountability. When I see the name I can begin to decide if this person ought to know something about the subject. We can look further to see if he actually does. We can find out if he made mistakes in the past, or if he enjoyed a career of unregulated evil. We can look up the history of the thing. What characteristics has it displayed in the past? What kind of record does it have? What’s the batting average?
But the ability to follow up, to check, to verify, to look up the footnotes will no longer exist. You won’t need to look stuff up. AI will know everything about everybody. It will have complete knowledge, so let’s just call it perfect knowledge or godlike knowledge. What could possibly go wrong?
At recent hearings, the people creating this monster told us it was a good thing overall, but that government should be involved to make sure it doesn’t become a bad thing. Wow. They’ll team up to make sure it works for the good of all. Well, that will make everything just dandy. I feel much better now. Go ahead and enslave us all but tell us after it’s too late. It’s for our own good, right?
So anyone wishing to avoid responsibility will find the capabilities of AI mesmerizing. For the rest of us the only sensible response to this isn’t just “No.” It’s “Oh, Hell no!”