‘Mythunderstanding’ consensus
Recently, especially in the domain of climate science, some parties have suggested that consensus be used to determine which of several competing theories is correct. This suggestion illustrates a profound misunderstanding of how science operates. Consensus is the result of a political process, general agreement is a result of science. From the outside, the two look much the same, but are actually radically different.
In consensus, the various parties meet, discuss, and arrive at a mutually acceptable position. Essentially it is a majority choice process where the participants agree to accept the consensus position. Conversely, in science, individual scientists can look independently at the available data and proposed explanations and decide for themselves if they find the explanations satisfactory. If the data is good and the explanations address objections, a majority of scientists might express the opinion that they consider the explanation to be true. This commonality of opinion is not consensus, although it may look like it. The difference is between a position arrived at independently based on thoughtful consideration of objective data, and a position arrived at through a democratic process which may be independent of objective data.
I have had the bemusing experience of being accused of gathering at conferences with fellow scientists to decide what is to be the nature of reality through some sort of consensus, as though we met to agree on such things as what should be the speed of light, much as the Indiana Pi Bill proposed in 1897 tried to establish the ratio of the circumference of a circle to its diameter by fiat. I can assure you, that unlike the Postmodernists of the Left, we are not attempting to define reality, but rather to discover it.
So how did we get here?
Prior to the Second World War, science was mostly the province of wealthy individuals, monks in monasteries, a few academics, and some in industry. Funding was seldom tied to specific results. Given the success of scientific contributions to the war effort in WWII, notably the Bomb, governments recognized the value of the fruits of scientific investigations.
At that time, funding for science became a national priority, and politicians began directing the sorts of results they hoped to see. That progressed to where politicians began directing scientists to produce the results that would support their particular policies. Funding became a tool of politics used to get the desired answers. Today, nearly all research is government funded through various agencies issuing grants and research contracts.
We now see grant offerings along the line of "This grant is to support research showing the effect of CO2 in promoting climate change, with particular interest in policy recommendations for mitigation." The same sort of direction exists in medicine, physics, biology, and every other field of science. There is little support for actual discovery. The emphasis now is on proving a point.