As with solar panels, wind turbines, including their blades, are made by energy-intensive processes. They also incorporate many materials that are, in turn, mined – using machinery, fuel and processes that environmentalists generally condemn. The Manhattan Institute notes “…building a single 100-MW wind farm— never mind thousands of them—requires some 30,000 tons of iron ore and 50,000 tons of concrete, as well as 900 tons of non-recyclable plastics for the huge blades.”
Onshore wind ‘farms’ bring arrays of dozens of wind turbines, dominating large swathes of land. The potential areas impacted are of orders of magnitude greater than the base area of turbines’ towers, encompassing expanded safety zones. Hannah Ritchie, of Oxford Martin Programme of Global Development, has calculated the average land use for onshore wind farm projects globally at about ninety-nine square metres per MW of power capacity – this about one hundred hectares per one GW facility serving about 700,000 people. Nuclear and gas-fired power plants need much less land: three or thirteen hectares each, respectively.
Turbine blades are deadly to birds and bats, including endangered species. John Merriman, the Bird-Smart Wind Energy Campaign Director at the American Bird Conservancy, calculates annual U.S. turbine-caused deaths of birds alone exceed one million. This includes collisions or electrocutions via dedicated power lines connecting turbines to the grid. In one meta-analysis, the bat fatality rate was three times that of birds. U.S. wind capacity was 1,075 MW in 2022, while global capacity is 837 GW. If U.S. bird and bat fatality numbers are proportionate worldwide, a staggering 779 million birds and over two billion bats could be being killed annually.