WhatFinger

Torture, Terrorists

An Alternate “Rendition”



The new political terror thriller "Rendition" has been released at a very opportune time. Now while many movies are bombing at the box office, this being one of them, the topic of torture in regards to terror suspects is one of those moral dilemmas that just won't go away.

When is it okay to torture a terror suspect? I'm sure some of you have heard that question posed: if a suspect may know of a nuclear weapon set to go off in an American city within the next few hours, do we observe his (or her) human rights and ask nicely? If that suspect doesn't answer and we're reasonably sure he or she knows where the bomb is, should we go Jack Bauer on the suspect, or conceivably give up a city in order to maintain our moral high ground? Politics being what it is today, it would be a lose-lose for that government official who decided to let a city and millions of people burn. But if we "extracted" the information and saved the city, the government official would probably still be vilified for using savage tactics. The ACLU, and every human rights organization outside of The Hague would be calling for war crimes charges to be filed. So what we do? While you'll need to see the movie to get specifics, here's how IMDB.com's (the Internet Movie Data Base) plot summary for the movie "Rendition" presents the question to the viewing audience...
When Egyptian born terrorism suspect, Anwar El-Ibrahimi disappears on a flight from South Africa to Washington DC, his American wife, Isabella travels to Washington to try and learn the reason for his disappearance. Meanwhile, at a secret detention facility somewhere outside the US, CIA analyst Douglas Freeman is forced to question his assignment in an attempt to save thousands as he becomes a party to the unorthodox interrogation of El-Ibrahim. When an Egyptian terrorism suspect "disappears" on a flight from Africa to Washington DC, his American wife and a CIA analyst find themselves caught up in a struggle to secure his release from a secret detention facility somewhere outside the US.
So, America is the bad guy in this whole thing, and with the pending confirmation of Michael Mukasey as the next Attorney General, and his answer/non-answer regarding torture, it seems that Hollywood and the left are on the same page again. Our old pal, Amy Goodman, hostess of Democracy Now! sees the issue like this....
AMY GOODMAN: As the Senate Judiciary Committee prepares to vote today on the nomination of retired judge Michael Mukasey to be attorney general, the issue of waterboarding and torture is at the top of the agenda. Mukasey has refused to condemn waterboarding as a form of torture, yet his approval by the Judiciary Committee seems all but assured, after two Democrats on the panel said they will support him--that's Schumer and Feinstein.
One of the ever-revolving themes here is how quickly people like Goodman and the "blame America's first" crowd seemingly always show more concern for our enemies than Americans and our interests. At least they're consistent...
While the practice of waterboarding is getting mainstream coverage, another controversial Bush administration tactic is also being thrust into the mainstream spotlight: extraordinary rendition. A new Hollywood movie starring Jake Gyllenhaal and Reese Witherspoon is called Rendition, centers around the story of an Egyptian US resident who is captured by US agents at a US airport, flown to a North African country to be tortured.
Again, I don't see anything in the plot synopsis to alert me to the fact if that US resident was or was not guilty as charged. I guess that's why they want us to go and see the movie no one is going to see.
Then, tonight PBS's FRONTLINE/World program is featuring a new documentary called Extraordinary Rendition. It's an international investigation by the award-winning journalist Stephen Grey, who first tracked the CIA's rendition flights in 2004. His book is called Ghost Plane: The True Story of the CIA Torture Program. The documentary features interviews with victims of extraordinary rendition speaking for the first time on US television. This is an excerpt of Stephen Grey's investigation. STEPHEN GREY: For years, I pursued the story of Bisher al-Rawi, an Iraqi-born British resident who once acted as a messenger between an al-Qaeda suspect in London and British Intelligence. In 2002, while he was on a business trip to Gambia in Africa, the CIA had al-Rawi and several colleagues arrested. He says he was betrayed by his British handlers, who turned him over to the Americans. Al-Rawi now finds it painful to recall his treatment by the CIA. BISHER AL-RAWI: They took me into a room. They sort of stripped me, cut off my clothes. And, you know, they just did their stuff, which I don't feel comfortable or necessary to go through, but it's not very pleasant, not very nice, and very, very humiliating, very intrusive. STEPHEN GREY: Al-Rawi was bound, gagged and hooded by the Americans. They drugged him with a suppository, dressed him in a diaper and a jumpsuit and put him on a plane. He was tied down in the same way as the US military secure enemy combatants captured on the battlefield. BISHER AL-RAWI: I was restrained from all--you know, feet, torso, chest. Of course, I can't see anything, like, you know, I can't see. I can't hear. You know, my ears are blocked. I was in a lot of pain. And I was sort of counting the seconds, actually just counting one second, two seconds, just like that, really, just hoping that it's going to be over soon, it's going to be over soon. And then the aircraft landed. Now, they're going to take us out of the aircraft. Now, now, now. They didn't. AMY GOODMAN: An excerpt of the FRONTLINE/World investigation into extraordinary rendition, airing tonight, 9:00 p.m. Eastern time on PBS stations around the country.
Bisher al-Rawi was reunited with his family in England after more than four years in military custody at Guantanamo Bay. So when are we, as a nation, allowed to defend ourselves and how far should we be allowed to go to do so? Remember, many of the people going off on the Bush Administration for not doing enough to stop the 9/11 attacks. What do you think Amy Goodman and Stephen Grey would be saying if it were discovered we had a suspect in custody with knowledge and we didn't get the information in time. All those who call the president a "murderer" today, would just add 3,000 to the number of people they claim he's killed. Now, according to Grey's publisher,
"In December 2005, Condoleezza Rice, the US Secretary of State, assured the world that the flights of CIA private jets that have criss-crossed Europe since 9/11 had no role in the sending of prisoners to be tortured. 'The United States has not transported anyone, and will not transport anyone, to a country when we believe he will be tortured,' she said. Tony Blair assured Parliament: 'I have absolutely no evidence to suggest that anything illegal has been happening here at all.'" "But as Stephen Grey reveals in "Ghost Plane", Rice's claims were a falsehood - and Britain's government has also turned a blind eye to a CIA operation that systematically out-sourced the harsh interrogation of its captives. Interviewing sources from the most senior levels of the current and former US administration, from the CIA's department of operations, Grey reveals how the agency's program, known by the euphemism 'extraordinary rendition', has transported hundreds of prisoners to foreign jails and its own secret facilities in the full knowledge they will face harsh torture. 'Of course we do torture', one former senior CIA operative told Grey."
Unfortunately, there is a good chance that CIA operatives are facing this moral dilemma every day. I trust that when they apprehend a suspect, they are very, very sure that they are not about to interrogate an innocent person. Unfortunately, there are not very many ways to find out if that person is innocent or not. Funny, how we didn't start this war. The problem are those on our side who don't even want us to be able to fight it. Welcome to the war on terror, and our place in it.



Subscribe

View Comments

Bob Parks——

Bob Parks is a is a member/writer of the National Advisory Council of Project 21. Bob’s websites are Black & Right and youtube.com/BlackAndRight


Sponsored