Are Fox Viewers Most Misinformed?
UMD study was run with funding from the Tides Foundation, which counts Soros as a major funder
According to a new study from the University of Maryland, those who regularly watch Fox News are most misinformed, in comparison to those who glean their news from other sources. Yet, this study--already being trumpeted by Left--has some notable flaws.
Dana Loesch at BigJournalism has pointed out one problem with the study: that it was in part funded by George Soros. Soros is known for funding all sorts of projects and companies, including Media Matters, that further his own personal agenda and beliefs. Loesch discovered that the UMD study was run with funding from the Tides Foundation, which counts Soros as a major funder. Blogger Warner Todd Houston found that the study was also funded by "such far left-wing organizations as the Ben and Jerry's Foundation, the Ploughshares Fund, [and] the United States Institute of Peace."
Of course, merely having a left-wing billionaire involved in the funding of a study does not automatically make it flawed. What makes a study flawed is bad methodology. And this study has plenty of that.
Twelve of the study's 43 questions asked were not released to the public in the study's formal Questionnaire with Findings and Methodology. Instead, each question was marked to be "released separately." It is unclear where or when those questions will be released. The missing questions make up over a quarter of the entire study.
Of the questions that were made publicly available, however, there are obvious flaws. The study partially addresses these flaws, but they are still problematic if we are to take the study seriously.
As an example, take the following questions:
Q15. How do you think economists viewed the TARP bank bailout[?]
Q21. What is your impression of how ECONOMISTS viewed the idea of stimulating the economy in this way?
Here, the study is asking for perceptions about economists generally. Yet, the study does not count economists generally: the study counts the official findings of government agencies as though they represent all economists. Examine the following from the study's overview (emphasis added):
Voters' misinformation included beliefs at odds with the conclusions of government agencies, generally regarded as non-partisan, consisting of professional economists and scientists.
- Though the Congressional Budget Office (CBO) concluded that the stimulus legislation has saved or created 2.0-5.2 million jobs, only 8% of voters thought most economists who had studied it concluded that the stimulus legislation had created or saved several million jobs. Most (68%) believed that economists estimate that it only created or saved a few jobs and 20% even believed that it resulted in job losses.
- Though the CBO concluded that the health reform law would reduce the budget deficit, 53% of voters thought most economists have concluded that health reform will increase the deficit.
- Though the Department of Commerce says that the US economy began to recover from recession in the third quarter of 2009 and has continued to grow since then, only 44% of voters thought the economy is starting to recover, while 55% thought the economy is still getting worse.
Read next: Viewers like you
Email Us | Reader Friendly | Comments
Guest Column——Bio and Archives
Items of notes and interest from the web.
