Earlier this year, Tennessee had to halt the execution of Tony Carruthers, “who was convicted of kidnapping and murdering three people in 1994.” Staff members were unable to “establish an intravenous line” after one hour of trying. After that debacle, Governor Lee ordered a one-year reprieve for Carruthers before another execution attempt.
This is a travesty for the family members of the three victims of Carruthers who are still waiting for justice after 32 years. It is also cruel and unusual punishment for Ms. Martinez and her family. She said, “Here we are, 31 years, and you're laughing in my face again…that’s what I feel like they did.” She told a Jacksonville, FL television station that her motivation was simple: “All I wanted was justice.”
After this failure, Colleen Slemmer and her family still have no justice. It is outrageous that Pike and so many other convicted murderers remain on death row in Tennessee and other states for years. As British Prime Minister William Gladstone said in 1868, “Justice delayed is justice denied.”
For too many victims and their families, these insufferable delays are a total denial of justice. In our criminal justice system, the priority is too often placed on the convicted murderers and not on the innocent victims.
The push for lethal injections was initiated to limit the pain of the convicted murderers. Since it is difficult to secure the proper drugs, and there are obvious problems in the administration of lethal injection, it is time to revert to methods that are much more reliable: the electric chair, lethal gas, and the firing squad.
It is also time to stop allowing convicted murderers to determine who is on their execution team. In Pike’s case, she demanded all-female executioners, and, for some reason, Tennessee complied with her demand. When did state officials start taking orders from murderers?