For instance, in Watkins v. United States (1957), the Supreme Court indicated that "The power of Congress to conduct investigations, inherent in the legislative process, is broad, but it is not unlimited", but it failed to spell out a complete list of limitations of such a presumed power. This is a major flaw of the case law (the Court's decision) that is not submitted to nearly as much debate, checks, and scrutiny as the legislative acts are.
Below, is a (non-exhaustive) list of proposed limitations that need to be expressly imposed on any Congressional investigation that pertains to political matters:
- No hypocrisy allowed. (What standards of conduct did the President violate that the majority party and its officials, in particular, past Presidents, are scrupulously following, and why does such violation fall into the category of "high crimes and misdemeanors"?)
- No selective prosecution allowed. (Are political adversaries prosecuted and sternly punished for every violation they might have committed, no matter how small, technical, or inconsequential, while political allies are not?)
- Presumption of innocence is mandatory.
- No weaponization of Congressional power for political or partisan advantage allowed.
- No tampering with evidence or witnesses allowed.
- No "fishing expeditions" (subpoenas, searches, and interrogations in search for a crime) and campaign "dirt" research allowed.
- Due process of law is mandatory.
- All 6th Amendment protections are mandatory, except that "an Impartial jury of the State and district wherein the crime shall have been committed, which district shall have been ascertained by law" is replaced by "The Senate of the U.S.".
As of now, none of the above have been articulated, and the House's majority shows no signs of intention to self-constrain itself along these lines.