The Ratification Debate Part Two
New Speak is nothing new in politics, and the concept of words having power to shape reality was not invented by George Orwell
Picking up where I left off in my review of the ratification debate I want to address the question I raised at the end of last week's essay, "What was the problem?"
If the government as established under the Articles had so many successes how did it end up being replaced by the government as established under the Constitution?
There were some perceived and actual weaknesses of the government as established under the Articles of Confederation:
- The national government was too weak as compared to the State governments.
- There was only a unicameral legislature and thus there was not a separate executive department to carry out and enforce the acts of Congress.
- There was no national court system to interpret the meaning of the laws passed by Congress leaving them open to differing interpretations.
- .Congress didn't have the power to levy taxes. It was instead dependent on State donations, which were levied on the basis of the value of land within the various states.
- Congress did not have the exclusive right to coin money. Each state retained the right to coin money. Without a uniform monetary system the coins of one state might not be accepted in another, hampering commerce.
- There was no mechanism to adjudicate disputes between the states.
- The Individual States were not precluded from having their own foreign policies including the right to make treaties.
- Each State had one vote in Congress with no respect to size or population.
- It required nine out of the thirteen states to approve the passage of major laws, approve treaties, or declare war.
- The amendment process was cumbersome requiring a unanimous vote.
Email Us | Reader Friendly | Comments
Dr. Robert R. Owens——Bio and Archives
Dr. Owens teaches History, Political Science, and Religion. He is the Historian of the Future @
drrobertowens.com
Follow Dr. Robert Owens on Facebook or Twitter @ Drrobertowens / Edited by Dr. Rosalie Owens
