Liberty Counsel is also asking the High Court to overrule Hill v. Colorado, a decision released by the Supreme Court in 2000. This case held that a statute prohibiting “oral protest, education, or counseling” with individuals attempting to enter a health care facility was content-neutral, despite the fact that police officers had to review the content of the speech to determine if it was covered by the law. The Third Circuit’s practice of relying on Hill to categorize buffer-zone laws as content-neutral speech restrictions distorts the First Amendment. The High Court’s subsequent decisions in McCullen v. Coakley and Reed v. Town of Gilbert found that laws restricting speech based on its function or purpose are content restrictions, “regardless of the government’s benign motive, content-neutral justification, or lack of ‘animus toward the ideas contained’ in the regulated speech.”
The Third Circuit’s reliance on Hill is erroneous and the Supreme Court should officially overturn Hill.
Liberty Counsel Founder and Chairman Mat Staver said, “The City of Harrisburg clearly violated the First Amendment by enforcing a policy that prohibits pro-life speech but allows other speech within the buffer zone. There is no contradictory testimony in nearly 10 years of litigation about the interpretation, application, and enforcement of the ordinance being a content-based restriction on pro-life speech. However, the Third Circuit’s decision brushes off the undisputed testimony by saying these enforcers who speak on behalf of the city ‘misinterpreted’ their own ordinance. Now the Third Circuit has created a split in the courts that the High Court must resolve. Until the Supreme Court overrules Hill v. Colorado, lower courts will continue to distort the First Amendment.”