The case centered around a legal challenge by Planned Parenthood arguing current law allows abortion so the Civil War-era ban should remain blocked. In June 2022, an Arizona appeals court evaluated the 1864 law and denied it from retaking effect favoring a more recent and less restrictive 15-week ban currently in place. However, with today’s Arizona Supreme Court ruling, not only will the 1864 near-total ban soon retake effect, the criminal and regulatory sanctions from the 15-week ban that penalizes physicians for performing abortions after 15 weeks will also remain in effect.
Liberty Counsel filed an amicus brief in the case urging the Court to reinstate the 1864 ban to protect unborn minority and disabled children from the social eugenic agenda of the abortion industry.
In deciding the case, the Arizona High Court did not weigh the law on whether the state constitution guaranteed a right to life or abortion, rather it evaluated the state’s abortion laws in their “proper context” to determine the legislature’s desired effect from the laws.
The Court stated the “the legislature made its intent known” by not repealing the 1864 ban and by declaring in the state code that the rights of the “unborn child” were limited only by the U.S. Supreme Court’s interpretation of the Constitution. Essentially, the Court stated that “due to Roe’s demise,” Arizona’s abortion laws have become “discernible comprehensive trigger provisions.”