Judge Ho also questioned the FDA’s use of an accelerated and less rigorous process to approve mifepristone. According to attorney Erin Hawley, who represents the pro-life medical groups, the FDA improperly classified pregnancy as an illness to give the drug expedited approval. Judge Ho questioned whether the drug was put into the correct regulatory category due to pregnancy not being an illness.
“Pregnancy is not a serious illness,” Judge Ho said.
Danco Laboratories attorney Jessica Ellsworth counterargued that the FDA acted properly and uses words like “illness,” “disease,” and “condition” interchangeably. Ellsworth noted that the FDA uses the same process for other non-serious conditions such as infertility.
Judge Ho asked, “When we celebrated Mother's Day, were we celebrating illness?”
Much of the
discussion was devoted to the claim by the Biden administration and
Danco Laboratories that the plaintiffs had no legal standing to file the
lawsuit because they were not directly harmed by the FDA’s approval of
the abortion pill. On behalf of the plaintiffs, Hawley argued they
indeed were harmed having been “forced to participate” in abortion
against their conscience when women sought emergency care after taking
mifepristone.
“They allege that they feel complicit in an elective abortion by being forced to complete that procedure,” Hawley said.
Judge Cory
Wilson asked, “Does the approval of any drug that triggers a conscience
concern in the part of a doctor give that doctor standing to bring a
suit? Where do you draw the line?”
Hawley
insisted the doctors have legal standing because they had been forced to
violate their consciences by helping “complete” an abortion and that
being involved again would subject them to “irreparable harm.”