In Tennessee v. Cardona, Judge Reeves had previously barred the Title IX update across six states in July 2024. Judge Reeves again sided with Tennessee and granted the state a final judgment that the rule is unlawful. In his decision, Judge Reeves noted every court that has weighed in on this Final Rule has also deemed it unlawful. He concurred that it was indeed so on “numerous fronts.”
Judge Reeves determined the rule violated the First Amendment because it would have chilled speech and compelled people to use “gender-identity-based pronouns” and affirm beliefs with which they disagreed. Secondly, he also stated the Department of Education exceeded its authority to expand the definition of sex, which is a role that solely belongs to Congress. And thirdly, Judge Reeves determined that expanding the definition of “sex” was “arbitrary and capricious” because the “starting point” and “ending point” of that definition is clear – “sex” means discrimination on the basis of being a male or female.
Judge Reeves concluded that these rewrites “fatally taint the entire rule.”
The Biden-Harris Administration announced it will no longer pursue efforts to rewrite the rule as the administration prepares to leave office.
Liberty Counsel Founder and Chairman Mat Staver said, “The defeat of this radical Title IX rewrite is a massive victory for women and girls. Title IX is once again a law that protects the privacy, safety, and fairness for women and girls in schools. The gender ideology experiment has no place in education and can now be purged from government rules.”