When leaders view rights as coming from government rather than God, history shows that religious freedom is often one of the first casualties
And now, in America, as several “democratic socialist” candidates recently won mayoral races in New York City and Seattle, it’s important this Christmas season to understand how socialism can evolve into communism—and what that could mean for religious freedom and openly celebrating Christmas.
Mayor-elects Zohran Mamdani in New York City and Katie Wilson in Seattle campaigned on policies like state-owned housing, wealth redistribution, and progressive taxes. Whether through civic ignorance or ideological alignment, these victories reflect a growing acceptance of government dependency.
According to a November 2025 Cygnal survey, only 16 percent of Americans understand socialism as co-author Karl Marx defined it in “The Communist Manifesto.” Marx and Friedrich Engels, both forefathers of communism, described socialism as the “lower phase” of communism, where production is publicly controlled for social welfare and equal distribution. They defined communism as going one step further where society demands from each person according to their ability and gives back only according to their needs.
When leaders view rights as coming from government rather than God, history shows that religious freedom is often one of the first casualties.
In socialist and especially communist systems, the state often positions itself as the highest moral authority. Independent belief systems—especially Christianity—are viewed as rivals. This tension has historically led to the secularization of religious rites or outright banning of religious holidays, practice, and expression.