The Court
noted, “Braidwood maintains that it has sincere and deeply held
religious beliefs that heterosexual marriage is the only form of
marriage sanctioned by God, pre-marital sex is wrong, and ‘men and women
are to dress and behave in accordance with distinct and God-ordained,
biological sexual identity.’ To that end, the EEOC guidance almost
assuredly burdens the exercise of Braidwood’s religious practice.”
The Court’s
opinion acknowledged that Title VII put Braidwood between “two untenable
alternatives.” The alternatives were either violate the law and obey
their convictions or obey the law and violate their convictions.
“We see no
reason why that formulation is incorrect,” stated the Court. “Being
forced to employ someone to represent the company who behaves in a
manner directly violative of the company’s convictions is a substantial
burden and inhibits the practice of Braidwood’s beliefs…That is
precisely what RFRA is designed to prevent.”
While
Braidwood requested class-action status in the case on behalf of other
religious businesses, the judges denied that request because the court
could not “determine whether the employers’ codes of conduct are similar
enough in practice to Braidwood’s that their lawfulness can be resolved
“in one stroke.” The ruling means that the exemption only applies
directly to Braidwood.
Liberty
Counsel Founder and Chairman Mat Staver said, “The unanimous decision
from the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals is a tremendous victory for
religious freedom. America was founded on religious principles, and they
are not just set aside during business hours. Businesses must remain a
free space for employers to operate in a manner consistent with their
faith and convictions. This ruling confirms the broad protection the law
gives religious businesses to employ people with aligned beliefs and
conduct.”
Liberty Counsel provides broadcast quality TV interviews via Hi-Def Skype and LTN at no cost.