As for the orphanages created by the Catholic Church and run by various order of nuns, one Grey Nuns sister administering to orphaned and other children at the Sacred Heart Hospital wrote in 1867 that:
“I must give you a few instances to show you what is the depth of the moral misery which we are called on to relieve. What I tell you will shock you to hear, as it sickens me to tell. It was a rather general custom of the savages in these countries to kill, and sometimes to eat, the orphan children, especially the little girls. Religion has made a great change in this respect, but infanticide is still by no means rare. A mother, looking with contempt on her newly-born daughter, will say, "Her father has deserted me; I am not going to feed her." So, she will wrap up the little one in the skin of an animal, smother her, and throw her into the rubbish heap…. Now you will quite understand that all these wretched people would rather have given their children to us than have killed them, or let them die.
“The barbarous deeds of fifty years ago are occasionally repeated even now, if the Convent Orphanages are far away. But the poor children are usually saved, to be brought to the Convent by some charitable neighbour.”
The complaint that the original tributes “did not include a critical consideration of their relationship with Indigenous peoples,” ignoring the elementary fact that this relationship included saving the lives of countless indigenous people, including many newborn infants.
Hymie Rubenstein, editor of REAL Indigenous Report, is a retired professor of anthropology, University of Manitoba, and a senior fellow at the Frontier Centre for Public Policy.