A three-judge panel sided with Dr. Allan Josephson, a psychiatrist in the university’s School of Medicine, who claimed six other medical school officials “retaliated” against him for having different opinions on how to treat children with gender confusion and for expressing those opinions at a panel discussion on the topic. According to the court’s ruling, Dr. Josephson spoke at a Heritage Foundation Panel in 2017 in his own “individual capacity” and not on behalf of the university. At the panel, Dr. Josephson questioned whether a child has the capacity to make major medical decisions and then shared his views that gender confusion has the “tendency” to diminish by the end of adolescence.
Dr. Josephson also stated at the panel that “gender dysphoria is a sociocultural, psychological phenomenon that cannot be fully addressed with drugs and surgery. Thus, doctors and others should explore what causes this confusion and help the child learn how to meet this developmental challenge.”
In the months following the panel, university officials demoted him from his role as a division chief to that of a junior faculty member, required him to make disclaimers while teaching, and subjected him to other forms of hostility and harassment. In February 2019, the university did not renew his contract ending his 40-year academic career.