NBI’s approach reflects a moral inversion: treating human industry and energy abundance as threats, rather than as achievements
What is most absent from the report is any genuine commitment to human flourishing. Energy is the foundation of modern life. Instead of vilifying emissions, investment leaders should champion innovation in reliable, affordable energy, including oil, gas, coal, and nuclear. A truly responsible investment framework begins with a clear-eyed, unbiased, full-context view of science, economics, and ethics, not ESG orthodoxy.
The deeper concern is NBI’s apparent breach of fiduciary duty. Canadian fiduciaries, under both common law and securities regulation, are bound to prioritize the financial interests of clients, not to champion external political and social causes. NBI’s decision to embed ESG into manager compensation and portfolio construction compromises this duty. A fiduciary’s primary obligation is to safeguard capital with sound, objective judgment, not to leverage client assets for social experiments.
At its core, NBI’s approach reflects a moral inversion: treating human industry and energy abundance as threats, rather than as achievements that have lifted billions out of poverty. As Alex Epstein, founder and director of the Center for Industrial Progress, argues in his book Fossil Future, the environmental and investment success of a project should be measured by how well human flourishing is advanced, not by how minimally it impacts the atmosphere. Energy is not our enemy; it is the enabler of clean water, abundant food, medical care, and global resilience.
If NBI truly wishes to lead, it must reject climate alarmism, scrutinize its assumptions, and re-anchor its investing philosophy around objective inquiry and the advancement of human well-being. That would be leadership worth investing in.
Dave McGruer is an Ottawa-based independent researcher. Tom Harris is Executive Director of International Climate Science Coalition – Canada.