In certifying the appeal, Senior Judge Norman K. Moon noted Zinski’s “sole claim” invokes Title VII sex discrimination raising the question of whether Liberty University is exempt from sex discrimination in order to uphold its religious doctrines. Judge Moon had previously recognized that after the Supreme Court’s decision in Bostock v. Clayton County, neither the Fourth Circuit nor the Supreme Court have clarified the interplay between Title VII’s statutory exemptions for religious institutions and individuals claiming to be “transgender.”
Judge Moon noted this is “no ordinary question” and there could be different outcomes of the appeal. He stated if the higher court finds that Title VII exempts Liberty University from sex discrimination, then it would be “wholly immune” from this lawsuit. He stated such a ruling could lead to the possible ending of the case saving Liberty University significant pre-trial effort and expense.
Liberty Counsel Founder and Chairman Mat Staver said, “The appeal certification allows Liberty University to appeal this critically important question of religious freedom which can result in controlling the outcome of the case. Zinski intentionally and deceptively set up Liberty University in an attempt to undermine its religious beliefs and mission. Title VII exempts Liberty University from having to employ individuals who violate its religious beliefs and doctrinal positions.”