This ruling conflicts with other decisions from the Circuit Courts of Appeal which have ruled in favor of health care workers fired for refusing the COVID shot, in which SCOTUS should be help resolve the split.
The First Circuit affirmed the district court’s decision to dismiss the case on mootness grounds, holding that the state’s rescission of the shot mandate meant the plaintiffs were no longer suffering any injury. However, the state rescinded the mandate right before the health care workers were going to have their first day in court, which meant that the state to this point has avoided any accountability for its unlawful and unconstitutional discrimination against religion.
The Court of Appeals said the health care workers have not properly challenged the text of the shot mandate, despite the fact the complaint stated numerous times—in every count—that it was a facial and as-applied challenge to the state’s unconstitutional and unlawful decision to prohibit religious accommodations to the shot mandate. The First Amendment requires that employers accommodate health care workers sincerely held religious beliefs, but the state prohibited any such religious accommodations. That is unlawful, and Liberty Counsel will ask the Supreme Court to correct it.
The Court also said there was no evidence the state rescinded the mandate as a litigation tactic, even though it came immediately after the First Circuit Court of Appeals’ prior decision entitling the health care workers to discovery and a trial on the merits. The state only rescinded the mandate to avoid having its unconstitutional shot mandate struck down.