Earlier this year, the elders of a church in a state in the mid-Atlantic region determined that the renovations the pastor was making to his property should be paid for by the church because the improvements were directly related and would directly benefit the church’s ministries. After hiring independent contractors to do the renovations, an OSHA Compliance Safety and Health officer (COSHO) inspected the property and subsequently subpoenaed the church with unnecessary questions and demands. Under the subpoena, OSHA was treating the church as an “employer” engaged in commerce rather than considering the pastor as a private “individual homeowner” just making improvements to his property.
While the pastor stopped work to meet some of the demands, such as supplying hard hats, safety glasses, and harnesses, he informed OSHA that his sole role was as a “homeowner” and that he was not controlling the contracting business doing the work. Yet, the COSHO escalated the issue over questions about the contract between the pastor and the contractors and subcontractors.
In the demand letter, Liberty Counsel stated that according to OHSA’s definition of “employer,” defined as “a person engaged in a business affecting commerce who has employees,” the pastor is a homeowner and is outside OSHA’s jurisdiction and standards.
As such, OSHA simply has no jurisdiction to issue a subpoena because a church reimbursing its pastor for home renovations does not constitute a business affecting commerce, nor does a residential homeowner constitute an “employer” by simply overseeing his home’s renovations, wrote Liberty Counsel. The “burdensome and intrusive nature of the subpoena” violates the First Amendment, Commerce Clause, and Religious Freedom Restoration Act by placing a “substantial burden” on the church’s free exercise of religion.