
Private Property Rights Under Attack by Comprehensive Land Use Plans
Private property must be guarded as priceless freedom. Land owners should reject the sustainable development idea that only government can protect nature, air, soil, water, open spaces, and the poor

If you ask the government, land belongs to the proprietor as long as the required taxes are paid in full each year and the government does not confiscate the property through eminent domain or deem it environmentally endangered and in need of protection. If you ask progressives, land belongs equally to everyone and nobody should be allowed to "own" anything, it should be communal property.
The painful lesson in communal property (communism) at Jamestown has been forgotten or never learned. When people worked the land together, some worked harder and some were lazier, yet everyone ate the same. The entire settlement almost starved to death. The following year, when the communal property was divided into individual parcels, everyone prospered.
Humans understood then that individual freedom and cooperation on smaller scale are much more successful than domination by a few in an exclusively government-run society.
The idea of Sustainable Development that emerged in 1987 from a conference by the World Commission on Environment and Development, chaired by Gro Harlem Brundtland, seemed innocuous. It was defined as "Development that meets the needs of the present without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own needs." It sounded lofty except for the nagging questions: who decides what the needs are, how are they going to parcel out the needs, how are they going to implement them, and who will police the decision-makers?
This call to Sustainable Development became the blueprint of a myriad of rules and regulations incorporated in the 1992 document called Agenda 21 signed by 179 nations at the U.N. Conference on Environment and Development in Rio de Janeiro in 1992. This 40-chapter document addresses every aspect of human life, not the least of which is property.
According to Henry Lamb, Bill Clinton's creation of the President's Council on Sustainable Development (Executive Order #12852, June 29, 1993) "was responsible for instilling sustainable development consciousness throughout every agency of the federal government," using enormous grant powers. These "vision" and "challenge" grants were given to state and local governments, to NGOs such as the American Planning Association, Sierra Club, and to HUD, DOE, and EPA to develop and implement community plans around the nation.
County-wide or region-wide plans by the years 2020, 2025, or 2030, contain 129 "visions" included in eight categories. These visions were developed at the first Glades County, Florida visioning meeting in February 2, 2006. They are eerily similar to the recommendations in the Agenda 21 document and in any sustainable development pamphlets. (Henry Lamb, Sustainable Development or Sustainable Freedom? pp. 5-6)
- Preserve natural environment
- Save/improve the wetlands
- Restrict development in sensitive areas
- Sustainable agriculture and farming
- Comprehensive resource preservation
- Never compromise wetlands or wildlife
- Preservation of scenic views
- Designation of scenic highways
- Development should be clustered
- Rural village concept
- Smart growth planned developments
- Increase density, increase walkability
- Impact fees that limit mobile homes
- Zoning should encourage infill
- More codes to be enforced
- Conservation easements on agricultural land
- Sidewalks, bike paths, and walking paths
- Multi-use trails and corridors that are landscaped
- Plan Bay Area violates voter-approved urban growth boundary ordinances, "nullifying these boundaries by restricting development to very small locations in just some cities"
- Plan Bay Area "violates the 5th Amendment of the U.S. Constitution by taking property rights without just compensation"
- Plan Bay Area "violates the 14th Amendment of the U.S. Constitution, the Equal Protection Clause" (Priority Development Areas land owners will receive permits 80 times more than owners outside of the PDA)
- Plan Bay Area "permanently strips all development rights from rural properties in the nine county Bay Area, effectively taking conservation easements on all rural lands without paying for them"
- Plan Bay Area "restricts development rights within the Priority Development Areas," limiting construction to mixed-use, high density Smart Growth development.
- Mud puddles become wetlands that must be protected
- Improving land by planting trees, bushes, filling a ditch with dirt, or building a fence can result in arrest and fine of the property owner under the Clean Water Act
- Building on one's land can be blocked
- If the area is deemed wetland, the owner can no longer use it or sell it
Read next: Private Property Rights Are the Key to Freedom
Email Us | Reader Friendly | Comments
Dr. Ileana Johnson Paugh——Bio and Archives
Dr. Ileana Johnson Paugh, Ileana Writes is a freelance writer, author, radio commentator, and speaker. Her books, “Echoes of Communism", "Liberty on Life Support" and "U.N. Agenda 21: Environmental Piracy," "Communism 2.0: 25 Years Later" are available at Amazon in paperback and Kindle.
