Radical Role-Play
I took a deep dive into one of the lessons taught by teachers in Portland, Oregon. At Grant High School, in a 9th grade class, students were asked to participate in a role-play mixer, in which they were assigned to play various historical figures in the Zionist movement along with roles as Palestinian peasants. And we thought kids dressing up as Pilgrims and Indians for Thanksgiving was culturally insensitive!
These students were asked to play 17 different roles that included Theodor Herzl, the Viennese “father of Zionism”; British Foreign Secretary Lord Balfour; Joseph Baratz, an idealistic young Zionist; Elias Sursuq, who “owned” and sold vast tracts of Palestinian peasants’ land to Zionist settlers; and Mahmoud Khatib and Ahmed Sharabi, who were Palestinian peasants. Students were asked “to internalize the information in their roles so that they could become this person in the mixer activity.” They also had the students speak only in an “I” voice while demanding that they not try to use accents for their role-play, noting that using an accent would be stereotypical and culturally insensitive. Still, I think this lesson has already gone far past that point.
Of course, the teacher opted to participate with the students in the role play “to make it more fun” and played the role of Elias Sursuq, the Beirut landlord whose family owned enormous parcels of what the teacher called “Palestinian land” that was acquired by “taking advantage of Ottoman laws that discriminated against poor and illiterate peasants.”
After the mixer, the students were asked to debrief, including asking the students who or what in Palestine’s early history was “guilty” of laying the groundwork or somehow contributing to today’s violence. All I can say after reviewing this shocking and offensive lesson is thank God Grant High School is primarily white students. Imagine assigning a Palestinian student to play the father of Zionism or having a Jewish student play a Palestinian peasant!