In their January 7 challenge to that decision, applicants David MacKinnon and Aris Lavranos argued that the Prime Minister’s reasons for proroguing Parliament for 11 weeks were unreasonable, serving only the partisan interests of the Liberal Party of Canada, not the interests of Canadians. And this - during a critical time marked by threats of redrawn international borders and steep tariffs on billions of dollars of Canadian trade.
Even Prime Minister Trudeau’s former Finance Minister, Chrystia Freeland, characterized the situation facing Canadians as a “grave threat.” The government itself had publicly claimed that the situation facing Canadians needed to be taken “extremely seriously.”
On March 6, 2025, Chief Justice Paul S. Crampton of the Federal Court ruled that Mr. MacKinnon’s and Mr. Lavranos’ challenge failed to show that the Prime Minister’s decision was illegal. He noted, “The Applicants failed to demonstrate that the Prime Minister exceeded any of the limits established by the written Constitution or by the unwritten principles they identified.”
While the Federal Court was right to find that a prime minister’s decision to advise prorogation can be reviewed by courts (and the federal government contested this point), Mr. MacKinnon and Mr. Lavranos argue that the Federal Court’s reasoning was flawed in dismissing the challenge.
Constitutional lawyer James Manson remarked, “After careful review of Chief Justice Crampton’s decision, our clients have concluded that the Court ruled correctly on several of the issues raised in this matter. Nonetheless, other important legal questions raised in this case, particularly concerning the limits of a prime minister’s authority to prorogue Parliament, remain unanswered.”