The Sixth Circuit was also skeptical about violations of equal protection. The Court cited the U.S. Supreme Court’s historic June 2022 Dobbs decision that overturned Roe v. Wade.
Judge Sutton stated, “The [SAFE] Act bans ‘gender-affirming care’ for minors of both sexes. The ban thus applies to all minors, regardless of their biological birth with male or female sex organs. That prohibition does not prefer one sex to the detriment of the other. If a law restricting a medical procedure that applies only to women does not trigger heightened scrutiny, as in Dobbs, a law equally applicable to all minors, no matter their sex at birth, does not require such scrutiny either.”
Circuit Judge Helene White, who partially dissented in both cases, stated that while she believes that both laws discriminate who can get “cross-sex hormones” based on sex, she concurs with allowing Tennessee’s law to take effect because the lower court “abused its discretion” applying the injunction to all people in the state rather than just to the plaintiffs in the case.
While Tennessee’s SAFE Act requires minors undergoing hormone treatments to stop by March 31, 2024, Kentucky’s version, one of the most protective in the nation, requires minors to begin weaning off current treatments immediately. Judge White would have kept the injunction against Kentucky in place due to believing the stricter timeline would cause “harm” to those already undergoing treatments at the time the law took effect.