In October
2022, a three-member panel of the Ninth Circuit ruled against Merritt
and Daleiden regarding numerous errors of the trial court, including:
(1) the award to Planned Parenthood of millions of dollars in “damages”
involving publication of Planned Parenthood’s own words, without any
proof that the undercover videos were false or deceptive, in violation
of the First Amendment; (2) the use of Racketeer Influenced Corrupt
Organizations Act (RICO) to punish constitutionally protected undercover
journalism intended to expose unethical and criminal wrongdoing; (3)
the award to Planned Parenthood of “damages” involving legally recorded
conversations without allowing the jury to hear those conversations, and
without requiring Planned Parenthood to prove that the conversations
recorded in public places were “confidential;” and (4) the failure of
the district court judge to recuse himself from this case, despite the
appearance of impropriety resulting from his connections to Planned
Parenthood.
In 2019, the
case was heard by San Francisco’s U.S. District Court Judge William
Orrick III, who is the founder of the Good Samaritan Family Resource
Center that houses the Planned Parenthood of Northern California
facility in its complex. In 2017, the defense requested that Orrick
recuse himself from the case and he refused. Judge Orrick severely
restricted the evidence, and at the end, gave instructions to the jury
on how they should rule on critical issues. The jury decided in favor of
the abortion giant on each count, including RICO, and awarded more than
$2 million in damages. The court subsequently awarded Planned
Parenthood nearly $14 million in attorney’s fees and costs, for a total
judgment of over $16 million.
Liberty
Counsel’s Founder and Chairman Mat Staver said, “Sandra Merritt is
asking the Supreme Court to review this case because the implications
will affect every investigative publication and journalist. Every
journalist and person who values free speech and a free press should be
concerned with the implications of the ruling from the Ninth Circuit
Court of Appeals.”