In the brief, Liberty Counsel stated that counseling bans have generated “a circuit split over a simple question: Is talk therapy that helps a minor with unwanted same-sex attractions or gender dysphoria conduct or speech?”
“…mental health counseling that helps a client align their feelings and behaviors with their religious beliefs and biological reality—unlike invasive medical procedures involving drugs and surgeries—is First Amendment-protected speech,” wrote Liberty Counsel.
Kaley Chiles is a licensed mental health counselor in Colorado who treats clients with issues related to addiction, trauma, gender confusion, and sexual attraction. However, Colorado’s law violates Chiles’ free speech rights by preventing her from helping those who are struggling with gender confusion, same-sex attractions and unwanted behaviors. The law authorizes fines of up to $5,000 per violation and suspension or even revocation of the counselor’s license.
In the brief, Liberty Counsel explained that Colorado, in order to censor dissenting viewpoints, “conspicuously ignored” studies that show talk therapy for unwanted confusion and same-sex attractions is safe and effective.
“This is not a consensus grounded in empirical rigor; it is a manufactured narrative that marginalizes alternative perspectives,” wrote Liberty Counsel. “But as history shows, such consensus often reflects not objective truths or science but the cultural and ideological preferences of a select group. … When courts rely on ‘expert consensus’ without scrutinizing its underpinnings, they risk enshrining ideology, not truth, into law.”