The Fourth Circuit became the fifth circuit court to side with Medicaid beneficiaries ruling that the federal Medicaid law creates “an individual right” to choose a provider, and ruled the law “bars states from excluding providers for reasons unrelated to professional competency.” The Appeals Court affirmed a lower court’s permanent injunction that keeps Planned Parenthood as a “qualified” medical provider in the state.
However, now that South Carolina has appealed to SCOTUS, it is not the first time the High Court has weighed in on this case. In June 2023, SCOTUS provided clear guidance for statutory interpretation when it ruled in Health and Hospital Corporation of Marion County v. Tavelski, a non-abortion case dealing with similar issues. In that case, SCOTUS determined that statutes must “unambiguously confer individual federal rights” for them to be enforceable as such. Using this ruling, SCOTUS vacated the Fourth Circuit’s ruling in Kerr directing the Appeals Court to reconsider its decision. Yet, the Fourth Circuit did not alter its ruling and now SCOTUS will fully review the case at some point in the Spring with a ruling expected in late June 2025.
Contributing to the circuit court split, the Fifth Circuit ruled in 2020 that Texas and Louisiana can defund Planned Parenthood. Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton cited the reason for Texas defunding the abortion giant was the undercover investigation by Sandra Merritt and David Daleiden that produced videos of Planned Parenthood trafficking human baby body parts.