Turner also noted the federal government is “misreading” the law and that “nothing in EMTALA” preempts Idaho’s law. He noted throughout today’s arguments that Idaho’s abortion law and EMTALA, as they are written, are not in direct conflict because EMTALA’s stabilization requirement requires doctors exercise their medical judgment in accordance with standards of care.
Justices Elena Kagan, Sonja Sotomayor, and Ketanji Brown Jackson all fervently pushed back on Idaho’s argument that the two laws do not conflict. Justices Sotomayor and Jackson noted EMTALA requires hospitals to “stabilize anyone” and that abortion is often the “stabilizing treatment.” But, in particular, Justice Kagan rejected the argument that medical regulation is strictly a state responsibility. She noted that EMTALA is “not all the state’s way” and may require abortions in not just life-threatening cases, but also when a woman could lose her ability to have children.
“Now that is the category of cases where EMTALA says, ‘my gosh,’ of course abortion is necessary,” stated Justice Kagan. “But Idaho says, ‘sorry, no abortion here’ and the result is these patients are now helicoptered out of state.”
While the three Justices gave little room for Turner to respond, he was able to quickly say that Idaho has a life-saving exception when the mother’s life is in danger, as well as that standards of care are determined by the state, and that doctors need to consider that there are two lives at stake.