According to the lawsuit, the HHS rule “creates a regime” of doctors and health insurers to silently perform and pay for these “harmful” and often irreversible procedures.
Ultimately the states and ACPeds are seeking an injunction to permanently block the rule arguing that HHS “arbitrarily” redefined “sex” to include “gender identity,” which exceeds its authority and “usurps” the role of Congress. They also allege the rule violates the rights of free speech, association, assembly, and unlawfully preempts state laws.
The rule imposes on doctors and health insurers a “no-win choice” of compromising their convictions, face financial punishment, or leave the field of medicine and abandon their patients, stated the lawsuit.
This legal challenge comes on the heels of four ongoing lawsuits against two other Biden administration rules. As per Biden’s executive order, these rules also infuse gender identity into the definition of “sex.” In these lawsuits, four federal courts have ruled against the Biden administration striking down these rules. Last week, a federal judge in Mississippi ordered a nationwide injunction blocking a different HHS Final Rule forcing states to use taxpayer dollars to pay for puberty blockers, hormones, and mutilating surgeries. Since June, three other U.S. district judges have blocked the Department of Education’s rewrite of a Title IX Final Rule which requires schools receiving federal dollars to force women and girls to share private spaces with gender-confused males. These three injunctions block the rule’s enforcement across 14 states, such as Alaska, Idaho, Indiana, Kansas, Kentucky, Louisiana, Mississippi, Montana, Ohio, Tennessee, Utah, Virginia, West Virginia, and Wyoming.
Currently, 25 states ban harmful puberty blockers, hormones, and mutilating surgeries for children.
Liberty Counsel Founder and Chairman Mat Staver said, “Doctors should never be forced to harm children and health insurers should never be compelled to pay for this radical agenda. Gender ideology is completely detached from science and reality. Courts should continue to strike down these rules.”