A majority of Democrats gave up on Christianity
The Democratic Party's reluctance to endorse the 19th Amendment, which granted women the right to vote, was undoubtedly a setback, but it was ultimately successful due to the strong support from the Republican states. Out of 36 states that ratified the amendment, 26 were Republican.
When Kennedy was president, liberalism was a positive place to be. At the time, being liberal meant focusing on individual freedoms and the government's role in protecting those freedoms. JFK played an active role in securing the rights for Blacks that everyone else enjoyed. The Democrats fought him tooth and nail. Many older Democrats stay in the party because they think JFK's spirit still exists there. It doesn't. JFK would be considered a conservative today.
The early progressive movement did manage to better regulate industrialization, urbanization, and immigration. They felt only government regulation could make the changes. The government did respond but was reluctant to overregulate or cease laissez-faire. When the Democrat Party absconded with the label, it took a mighty radical left turn starting in the 60s and 70s. It became a cultural change movement. Why?
Firstly, a majority of Democrats gave up on Christianity. A giant step was when the Supreme Court in 1962 decided that prayer in school no longer had a valid place. I grew up in the New York City public school system. No one today would accuse them of being conservative, but in the early 60s, our junior high school had an auditorium program every Wednesday where school plays and such were presented.