After a week-long trip to the Dominican Republic, Bauerle came back very ill with a food-borne illness that left him weakened and prevented him from sleeping.
“I wasn’t sleeping but 2 hours a night. I was in a very weak state and getting stressed out because I didn’t know what was taking place around me. Who would want to put heavy, almost lock-step surveillance on me? As the weeks rolled on, it didn’t make sense.
“I just didn’t know what was going on. All I could do was remain vigilant, keep my powder dry, and keep the cops, my friends and attorneys in the loop. After a while, I asked PI Douglas J. Hagmann to come investigate. Hagmann told Bauerle “It was a surveillance operation the likes of which he had never seen”.
‘Dude, something major, and we mean massive is going on around Bauerle’s house
Bauerle downloaded a free app called “Color Night Vision” and started using the app to take “night vision” photos and captured anomalies.
“By December 2013 , I eventually had to discard the idea that the person of whom I’d been critical in an animal cruelty case might be a logical suspect, because of what I learned as the duration and intensity of activity increased around my home. What did I find out? Unbeknownst to me, a dear friend who knows a lot of Special Forces guys asked some of his buddies to come to my neighborhood prior to Christmas, 2013. These are the kinds of guys from the movie 13 Hours. Totally badass. So these hombres came to my neighborhood, saw what was happening and reported to my buddy: ‘Dude, something major, and we mean massive is going on around Bauerle’s house.
Someone has to be spending tens of thousands of dollars a day on this guy. We’ve never seen anything like it. We’re talking advanced technology like we’ve never seen, and we don’t want to go back.’”
Bauerle’s friend broke the news to him that he was under major and high-tech surveillance just before Christmas 2013.
In the early-morning hours in late December 2013 and early January 2014, Bauerle would have his eyes on his security cameras and use “Color Night Vision” to try to get definitive proof, and on several occasions was sure he was seeing people.
Try explaining a form of surveillance so sophisticated that it put private detectives on the run to the police and remaining in the sane zone.
After several calls to the Amherst Police, officers eventually wanted him to undergo a psychiatric evaluation in early January 2014. “It was bitterly cold then, and my cell phone would die after a few minutes outside, so it was very frustrating trying to explain what I was seeing. What I couldn’t understand was why there were no footprints where there should have been. But now I know why. What I was seeing were not real people. Projections. Like holograms, or as some say “Phantom Bogeys.”
When Amherst Police requested Bauerle undergo a psychiatric exam at Erie County Medical Center (ECMC), it was made clear that if he did not voluntarily consent, he would be compelled to do so.
A savvy, rational Bauerle was cooperative with police at all times, and the officers saw no reason to even handcuff him during transport to ECMC.
In fact, the allegedly off-his-rocker Bauerle was allowed to walk into the Emergency Room under his own power, as he gave authorities his word of honor that he was not a danger to them or himself, and would not attempt to flee.
Trip to ECMC: "Wow. I am ordering your immediate discharge"
It was early on a Wednesday morning when Bauerle was admitted for a psychiatric exam at ECMC.
“The first doctor who examined me and spoke with me about why I was being psychiatrically evaluated was, I believe, Jamaican,” Bauerle recalls. “He was a kind man and listened to what I said about being under surveillance and why I reasonably believed I was, and that I had corroboration. After a 10 or 15 minute conversation he smiled, threw up his hands and said, ‘So WHY are you here?’ as he obviously could see I was lucid and coherent.”
“The second physician was a female, and I believe a resident. Let’s put it this way: I wasn’t very impressed. She asked ‘Why did you go outside with a loaded gun?’ I told her I was legally permitted to carry a firearm with an unrestricted pistol-permit and had been for almost 30 years without incident and even during an acrimonious divorce, my firearms had never been an issue. I then smiled and said, ‘Perhaps you could tell me of what use an unloaded firearm would be?’ I don’t think she liked that. They also had me speak to a male nurse once or twice and repeat what I had already said. After that, I waited and waited and waited.”
During transport to ECMC, Bauerle had asked the EMT team if he could send some texts to his attorneys and friends apprising them of this turn of events, and so after sunrise was able to advise his employer of what was taking place.
At some point during the day he was given a room on the psych floor at ECMC.
“A couple of nurses walked up to me in the hall and said, ‘None of us can figure out why you are even here.’ I laughed and told them I couldn’t either, and requested permission to take my meals in my room privately. The nurses said, ‘Of course. We completely understand.’
“The next day was Thursday, and I finally had the chance to speak with another doctor. She introduced herself as Dr. Marshall, and I requested that my cell phone and a charger be brought to my room before I told her my story, as there were photos on my phone and texts from third parties that she should see before she decided whether I was insane or not. Dr. Marshall, bless her soul, readily agreed. I gave her the condensed version of why I believed I was under surveillance, showed her texts from certain people confirming that I was under surveillance based on the November and December investigations. The coup de grâce was a photo I had taken using the color night vision app showing what appeared to be an individual taking a photo of me, as he peeked over my garden wall. The doctor’s skeptical demeanor changed 180 degrees, and she said: ‘Wow. I am ordering your immediate discharge.’ My attorneys and ex-wife came down to ECMC and I was home early Thursday afternoon. I called my boss and said I’d be on the air the next day. He asked, ‘Are you sure?’ And I told him that a coward might choose to stay home and hide, but as I am not a coward, that is where I needed to be.”
“Why wouldn’t I? There was nothing wrong with me,” he said.
Contrary to what WBEN and Bauerle-bashing Buffalo News columnist Alan Pergament indicated, WBEN did not force Bauerle on the air. Bauerle insisted on working. That was the Friday before the Buffalo News published its front page article on Sunday.
But on Sunday, more than a day after Bauerle had performed his 4-hour show flawlessly and with aplomb, the Buffalo News published a front page story about his behavior, being taken to ECMC and allegations making him seem like a lunatic.
“As far as the neighborhood meeting, I was the one who called it to explain what was going on,” he said. “I love my neighbors and wanted to keep them in the loop, but I couldn’t really offer much in the way of an explanation. And despite the ridicule, there are shoes people can buy online that mimic animal tracks. But until I solved the case, some couldn’t figure out why I wasn’t seeing footprints where I was seeing people. Hell, I couldn’t.”
In light of the vicious smear against him, WBEN offered Bauerle the following day off so he wouldn’t have to deal with the fallout and potential nasty callers.
Bauerle told his boss: “You must really think I’m a pussy. I’ll be on the air.”
He was given a corporate statement he had to read, and performed to perfection again.
Lucky that plucky Bauerle is the owner of a go-to kind of humour because he may never have made it back from Crazy Limbo without it. When a friend showed him the front page smear piece and asked him, “What do you think?” Bauerle responded with his typical humor: “They used a 20 year old picture! They didn’t use the hot one of me in my tuxedo! Those bastards!”