The call to develop friendly supply chains for critical minerals has grown louder in the past few years, with the deterioration in the geopolitical environment, the rising prominence of energy security and continuing urgency about de-carbonizing. Rare earth elements have always been on the geo-political radar, however, both because of China’s control of their mining and processing and its history of weaponizing its dominance through trade restrictions.
Eager to capitalize on the demand for non-Chinese sources of rare earths, Australia’s Vital Metals started extraction at the Nechalacho mine, 110 km southeast of Yellowknife, in 2021. It was touted at the time as a step towards loosening dependence on supplies from China. Vital even announced it was opening a processing facility for bastnaesite rare earth ore in Saskatoon, adjacent to a separate processing facility for monazite rare earth ore being developed by the Saskatchewan Research Council, a crown corporation. Visiting the Vital Metals facility in January 2023, Prime Minister Justin Trudeau said we “really need resilience in our supply chains.” Vital received $5 million in federal support for the project.
And then the market fell. Prices for rare earths sank through spring and summer 2023 as demand weakened and China continued supply, displacing new entrants in the market, presumably intentionally. Vital Metals was amongst the casualties. It paused construction of its Saskatoon processing facility in April 2023, and filed for bankruptcy of its subsidiary in September.