"Did Iran contract with the PFLP-GC? Probably! But it cannot be proven in court. Did Iran ask Libya and Abu Nidal as you stated in an earlier article? Perhaps, but that too cannot be proven and never will be unless a reliable witness or two comes forward with documentary evidence," said the FBI agent who led the Lockerbie investigation, who wrote to me. [2]
Former FBI Special Agent Richard A. Marquise was the chief of Terrorist Research and Analytical Center at FBI Headquarters in the '80s. In 2001, Marquise received the Attorney General Award for Distinguished Service.
"With regard to the James Baker discussion with a Syrian intelligence minister in 1989, I have no doubt the conversation occurred. At the time we strongly suspected the PFLP-GC which was sponsored by Syria. Baker was one of those people who could distinguish evidence from intelligence. His quote, if accurate, should have said we have the 'intelligence' but the word evidence connotes a stronger meaning so would have been more appropriate." [3]
"We believe the Iranians had a motive to attack an American plane and they may well have ordered the bombing, but the physical evidence only links Libya to the attack. Unfortunately it does not tie anyone else, only if we had an insider. It has been nearly 20 years and one would think that by now someone would have come out of the woodwork to make the claim if legitimate." [4]
This writer thus suggested to Marquise that Western intelligence had access to an insider with superb knowledge of the Iranian intelligence apparatus. Marquises' reply was, to say the least, disturbing.
"With regard to Mesbahi, I have never heard the name until reading it in your article. I have no idea who he is but guess the defense must have heard of him and wonder why he was not a key witness at trial. It seems, based on what you report, he has some significant info -- where -- what is it?? I have no way of knowing," Marquise wrote to me. [5]
Germany 1997
In July 1997, the magazine Der Spiegel reported that German prosecutors had interviewed Abolghasem Mesbahi, previously only known as witness "C", in a case concerning the assassination of Iranian dissidents in Berlin. [6]
Abolghasem Mesbahi is believed to be an alias. There is, however, no doubt that Mesbahi is a former high ranking Iranian intelligence official. It is alleged that he is the son of one of the fathers of the Islamic Revolution.
German Law Authorities came to regard Mesbahi as a credible witness. In fact, based on his testimony, an Iranian and three Lebanese were convicted of killing several Iranian Kurdish dissidents in Germany.
For the first time anywhere, Germany issued an international arrest warrant against a top ranking Iranian official, namely Iran's former Intelligence Minister Ali Fallahian.
Without naming them explicitly, the court declared that Grand Ayatollah Ali Khamenei and President Ayatollah Rafsanjani had authorized the assassination. Such ruling would have been all but impossible without Mesbahi's precise knowledge of Iran Intelligence apparatus.
Three weeks before the beginning of the trial, Fallahian flew to Bonn and met with the top German intelligence official in an effort to free the five suspects and stop the prosecution. The prosecutor, Bruno Jost, would later declare that the attempt to interfere with the trial clearly pointed to the murder having happened on Tehran orders.
Besides linking Iran to the killing of dissidents in Berlin, Mesbahi claimed that Iran was behind the 1988 bombing of Pan Am airliner. Tehran promptly attempted to dismiss his testimony as part of an anti-Iran campaign by Western media.
"I can say that a witness has been interviewed and that his testimony blames Iran," declared Job Tilmann, a spokesman for the Frankfurt prosecutors' office.
Mesbahi told investigators that Iran had asked Libya and Abu Nidal, a Palestinian guerrilla leader, to carry out the attack on the Pan Am 103, which was destroyed in flight by a small bomb on Dec. 21, 1988.
According to Mesbahi, Iran planned the attack as revenge after the US cruiser Vincennes shot down an Iran Air Airbus over the Strait of Hormuz a few months earlier in 1988. Few, who studied the Lockerbie bombing, doubt the veracity of this statement.
Dr. Swire lost his daughter Flora in the Lockerbie tragedy. On Jan. 11 of this year, Dr. Swire wrote to me that he never doubted who ordered the bombing, why they did it and who supplied the technology.
"As you know, I have always believed that it was Iranian revenge, whether or not the Libyans helped, and that the Syrians through Jibril supplied the technology."
In a remarkable article published on the Columbia Journalism Review message-board, Hart Lidov, who was engaged to Flora Swire, made it abundantly clear that he also shared this point of view. [7]
Mesbahi alleged that parts of the bomb were put on a plane at Frankfurt airport, later assembled in London and finally loaded onto Pan Am 103.
If "assembled" means "armed," this modus operandi is consistent with the bomb being the fifth IED built by Khreesat in October 1988 while he was working in Frankfurt for Jibril PFLP-GC. The fifth IED was never recovered. It was constructed to explode 38 minutes after takeoff, exactly when Pan Am 103 was obliterated.
Incidentally, Marquise is disputing the veracity of what I wrote previously concerning Khreesat.
"You mention a Dumfries and Galloway police report dated March 29, 1991, which blamed the attack on Khreesat. I do not think any such report was ever written -- especially at that time as we were on to the Libyans by that time," Marquise told me. Although the former FBI agent says that there may have been some documentation to this effect, he is adamant that no formal report was ever drafted. "I would have to read it to believe in it is real," Marquise told me. (NB. The report dates actually from March 1989 but was discussed by Dalyell in March 1991.)
I have not seen this report, but I have good reasons to suspect that such a report exists and that it was shown to Black. Marquise does not believe that the Scots ever drew up an arrest warrant for Khreesat because, according to his investigation, not one shred of evidence tied Khreesat to the bombing. At this point, I can only report a clear-cut disagreement between Marquise and Black, who claimed on several occasions that he had seen the report, that the report did not blame Libya and that the Scots were ready to issue an arrest warrant.
I will also add that Paul Foot referred to the report in an article written in January 1992. Foot even wrote that this document was "the information which had prompted the then-Transport Secretary Paul Channon on March 16, 1989, to announce triumphantly to selected lobby journalists that the Scottish police had tracked down the man who bombed the plane and would be arresting him shortly." (Foot actually wrote, I believe incorrectly, March 17.)
What is more, some authors have asserted that the warrant was never issued at the request of the FBI! "Scottish police actually wrote up an arrest warrant for Marwan Khreesat in the spring of 1989, but were persuaded by the FBI not to issue it because of his value as an intelligence source." [8]
On March 29, 1991, Tam Dalyell told the House of Commons that, the Dumfries and Galloway police issued a report entitled "Bombing of Pan Am 103 -- Interview of Marwan Abdel Razzaq Mufit Khreesat as a Suspect."
The Scottish police's report concluded: "There can be little doubt that Khreesat is the bomb-maker for the PFLPGC and there is a possibility that he prepared the explosive device which destroyed PA-103. As such he should not be at liberty."
"One of the problems with writing a report such as you refer with strong language is that there was no PROOF, no EVIDENCE which could back that up. It was an officer's assessment -- great intelligence -- but not proof that a prosecutor needs in court," argues Marquise
Mesbahi said that Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini personally ordered the revenge attack and that Foreign Minister Ali Akbar Velayati had carried out the planning with Libya and guerrilla leader Abu Nidal.
Velayati acquired his M.D. from University of Tehran and pediatrics degrees from the Johns Hopkins University in 1971 and 1974, respectively. He was the foreign minister of Iran for about 16 years (Dec. 15, 1981, to Aug. 20, 1997), making him the longest-serving foreign minister in Iranian history. Velayati is the only high-ranking Iranian official who kept his post after the death of Khomeini.