What can we learn from those examples that can be applied to Canada’s aboriginal population?
Fifth, historical trauma exists on a personal and a community level around the globe. Japan suffered the devastating effects of two atomic bombs and the loss of belief in the emperor as a direct descendant of God. Germany experienced the blanket firebombing of Dresden, the suicide of Hitler, and a resounding defeat by the allied forces. The country was then divided, with nearly one-third given to Russia. Meanwhile, Jewish families experienced the torture, starvation and murder of some six million of their relatives in the world’s largest and most carefully orchestrated genocide.
But Japan, Germany, and Israel have built strong, resilient, and democratic societies since that time.
What can we learn from those examples that can be applied to Canada’s aboriginal population? If we truly wish to help people give up victimhood and live fulfilled lives, we need to do things differently. We cannot continue to make victimhood the main avenue to financial gain. Rent seeking alone does not eradicate blame, anger, addiction, depression or anxiety, and the resulting dysfunctions.
Private property rights and the freedom to trade encouraged these societies and promoted individual achievement, upward mobility, and happiness. The tribal communal structure of Canadian aboriginal communities does not do this. On the contrary, it promotes elitism, autocratic dictatorship, and financial abuse.
If one remains a victim then one continues to live with blame, anger, depression and anxiety. The goal of life and therapy is to become an engaged participant, not to remain a victim. The key to this is forgiveness, both of others and oneself.
It is also immoral to continue to fund aboriginal groups based on a false history of trauma and to encourage a never-ending victim identity. It is immoral to fund aboriginal children to grow up on dysfunctional reserves. It is immoral to blame residential schools for all the problems on reserves when 70% of aboriginal children did not attend these schools.
Sixth, and most important of all, just as the remarkable commonality of false memories of Satanic abuse was not evidence of the truth of those remembrances, the unproven commonality of memories of residential school abuse is not evidence of actual abuse and murder, let alone genocide.
The only factual and moral grounds for supporting our fellow citizens is to demand evidence and accountability while embracing identical rights for all Canadians regardless of their ethnicity or life experiences.
Brian Talarico, MD, FRCPC, is a retired psychiatrist
Hymie Rubenstein, editor of REAL Indigenous Report, is a retired professor of anthropology at the University of Manitoba and a senior fellow at the Frontier Centre for Public Policy