Fiscal Waste During the Pandemic in Canada and the United States
Overall, it’s clear that over the long-term Canadians and Americans will face significant ongoing costs to pay for wasteful and poorly targeted government spending during the pandemic
During
the pandemic, governments around the world spent a significant amount
of taxpayer money in an effort to support their economies. This was
particularly true in Canada, with hundred billion-dollar programs such
as the Canada Emergency Wage Subsidy (CEWS) and Canada Emergency
Response Benefit (CERB), and in the United States, with nearly
trillion-dollar programs such as the Paycheck Protection Program (PPP),
Economic Impact Payments, and expanded and extended unemployment
programs. Given the significant cost of these programs, it’s important
to assess their efficiency or, rather, the degree to which they were
excessive, poorly targeted, or simply wasteful.
Canadian COVID
programs such as CEWS and CERB were ripe with problems including
overpayments, funds provided to individuals and businesses not in
genuine need, and excessive amounts of support that went above what was
required to stabilize incomes. In the United States, independent
analysis found excess unemployment payments, a poorly designed paycheck
protection program, and largely ineffective stimulus payments.
Each
country wasted billions in taxpayer money on their COVID responses,
which was financed entirely through borrowing. Canada’s federal COVID
spending totaled $359.7 billion, of which an estimated 25 percent ($89.9
billion), at a minimum, was wasted. Total federal COVID spending has
added $8.3 billion to present-day interest costs and we estimate
approximately $2.1 billion of that amount is attributable to wasteful
COVID spending. Over the next 10 years, Canada’s federal government is
projected to pay $21.1 billion in interest costs attributable to COVID
fiscal waste. Put differently, the cost of Canada’s COVID fiscal waste
will total roughly $111.0 billion by the end of 2032/33.
The
United States’ COVID spending response came at a price tag of nearly
$5.1 trillion and an estimated 25 percent ($1.3 trillion) of that
amount, at a minimum, was wasted. At least $28.8 billion of current
interest costs are directly connected to fiscal waste in the US during
the pandemic. Further, the US government will pay approximately $289.4
billion in interest payments over the next decade due to COVID waste. In
summary, the cost of the United States’ COVID fiscal waste will total
more than $1.56 trillion by the conclusion of 2032/33.
Overall,
it’s clear that over the long-term Canadians and Americans will face
significant ongoing costs to pay for wasteful and poorly targeted
government spending during the pandemic.
The Fraser Institute is an independent Canadian public policy research and educational organization with offices in Vancouver, Calgary, Toronto, and Montreal and ties to a global network of 86 think-tanks. Its mission is to measure, study, and communicate the impact of competitive markets and government intervention on the welfare of individuals. To protect the Institute’s independence, it does not accept grants from governments or contracts for research. Visit fraserinstitute.org.
Follow the Fraser Institute on Twitter | Like us on Facebook