According to Slattery, the Second Circuit ruled that a pregnancy center may have a valid First Amendment claim if it can prove that a law forces the organization to “employ individuals who act or have acted against the very mission of its organization.” This decision by the Appeals Court instructs how the lower court should scrutinize the issue and what standard these pro-life organizations must now meet to be successful in their expressive association claims.
Circuit Court Judge Sarah Merriam wrote, “The District Court did not have the benefit of the Slattery opinion — which is now binding precedent — when it issued the orders challenged in this matter. In light of Slattery, we vacate the dismissal of Plaintiffs’ expressive-association claim.”
Judge Merriam stated that entities like CompassCare could “plausibly allege” that New York’s law compels faith-based organizations to retain employees outside their belief system. However, she cautioned that expressive association rights are “not unlimited” and cannot “erect a shield against antidiscrimination laws,” so employers must show the law impedes a specific employment decision resulting in a detriment to the organization’s message.
Judge Merriam noted that all three of the pro-life organizations in this case will have to meet the standard set in Slattery “separately and independently” of each other where the outcome may differ for each organization.
Liberty Counsel Founder and Chairman Mat Staver said, “Christian employers are free to hire individuals who represent and convey the core principles of their organizations. The Second Circuit rightly reinstated this case so that these pro-life organizations have the chance to prove this New York law infringes on their expressive freedom to not employ or associate with those who do not align with their mission to protect preborn children.”