After 187,000 pages of discovery documents, 25 depositions, 127 pages of Undisputed Facts, about 500 pages of summary judgment legal arguments, the federal court ruled that the SPLC and their client, Janet Jenkins, presented no evidence to support their frivolous allegation that Liberty Counsel helped Lisa Miller flee the country with her two-year-old daughter in 2009 or her whereabouts. The court also ruled that Jenkins’ attempt to drag Liberty Counsel into the case in 2016 was barred by the statute of limitations. The court also found that Jenkins repeatedly contradicted her prior allegations.
Liberty Counsel wrote in opposition, “Jenkins has not and cannot demonstrate a controlling question of law, has not and cannot demonstrate that there is substantial ground for difference of opinion with the Court’s decision.”
Since Jenkins has no evidence to ever obtain a judgment against Liberty Counsel, her appeal claims are meritless, wrote Liberty Counsel.
The case arose from a custody battle where Liberty Counsel represented Miller to dissolve her Vermont civil union to Jenkins in 2004. When Miller moved to Virginia with her 2-year-old daughter, Isabella, the litigation to dissolve the civil union pitted the laws of Vermont against Virginia, which did not yet recognize civil unions or “same-sex marriage.” In a “first of its kind” case, a Vermont court recognized Jenkins as a legal parent of Miller’s daughter awarding her parent-child contact.
Miller complied until Isabella complained of abuse. While the cases were ongoing in both states, Miller suddenly fled with Isabella to Nicaragua. When Lisa Miller suddenly stopped communicating, Liberty Counsel informed the court it lost contact with her and sought to withdraw from the case.