The Failure to tell Right from Wrong: The Possible Collapse of Western Civilization
A culture of celebrating life and freedom and Justice is Right; A culture celebrating death and totalitarianism, injustice, and abuse is Wrong
- While the relatives of the murdered Fogel Family of Itamar were still in the seven-day mourning period for the “savage”, “barbaristic” butchering of 5 members of one family by members of a culture that features anti-Jewish incitement in their education system, media and mosques, Israel showed its character: An Arab woman from a nearby village, was delivering a baby which had the umbilical chord wrapped around its neck. Her family sent her by cab to the nearby Jewish town of Itamar, where Israeli medics were proud to save mother and baby, who the grateful family named “Jude”.
- A lovely video is available on the internet telling the story of how Israel has helped a young Haitian man, who lost his leg in the earthquake. This was particularly sad because he made his living as a talented dancer. Israeli doctors, who were among the first to get operating theatres up and running after the earthquake, took the young man back to Israel where they gave him a prosthesis and physical therapy that has resulted in him resuming his dancing career!
- Israel has Arab members of the Knesset, on its Supreme Court, and in its diplomatic corps. The Druze Arabs, who agree to support the state and serve in its army, have even had a Deputy Prime Minister from among their community in Israel. Abbas, (who wrote a thesis while studying in Communist Russia denying the Holocaust) of the Palestinian Authority has vowed that not one Jew shall be allowed to live in a future Palestinian state, at the same time as he calls for a “right” of return for all of the descendants of the approximately 750,000 Arabs who left Israel during the War of Independence, when Israel was attacked on all sides by Arab neighbours who were opposed to the United Nations partition of the land between Jewish and Arab states. Approximately the same number of Jews were ejected from intolerant Arab nations such as Egypt, Iraq, Syria, Libya, Tunisia, Algeria, Morocco and Yemen even though they had lived there for thousands of years. Israel of course took them all in. Most left-wing analyses of the Israel-Arab conflict do not bother to mention this fact.
- Israel, after due judicial process, just sentenced former president Moshe Katsav to seven years in prison for rape. In the Arab world, it is almost unheard of for a man to be tried for rape; unfortunately it is far more common for the woman to incur criminal sanction (such as stoning to death or permitted honour killing) for bringing dishonour to her family. Why have the Leftists abandoned review of human rights in a legal system as a basic form of morality? The answer unfortunately is that right and wrong are the first victims of cultural relativism. When CBS reporter Lara Logan learned first hand about the culture of rape in Arab countries, it was her very own news organization that feared publicizing what was already known on the internet, and this fear to me has more to do with offending the perpetrators than protecting the victim.
“The perversity of today's international outcry lies in the fact that there is indeed a disproportion in this war, a radical moral asymmetry between Hezbollah and Israel: Hezbollah is deliberately trying to create civilian casualties on both sides while Israel is deliberately trying to minimize civilian casualties, also on both sides.The concept of “proportionality” has never been applied to other Western nations. Like the concepts adopted by the anti-Israel left, the concepts and the subversions of language applied to Israel show nothing so much as an abandonment of traditional Judeo-Christian ethics in an effort to appease radical Islam. Islam has many theological problems that it will have to solve before it can hope to be called a “religion of peace.” Why call it a religion of peace when the Hadith (a record of the sayings of Mohammed) says: "The Day of Judgement will not come about until Muslims fight the Jews (killing the Jews), when the Jew will hide behind stones and trees. The stones and trees will say O Muslims, O Abdullah, there is a Jew behind me, come and kill him.” I am the son of a Holocaust survivor. My father lost his parents and then eight year old sister in the gas chambers of Auschwitz. I have degrees in History and Law from the University of Toronto (which last year, during the U of T’s hosting of Israel Apartheid Week, I returned to the University in protest and shame). After 40 years of the study of History, I am convinced that the moral measure of a society is how it treats its Jews, or now, how it treats the Jewish Homeland. Obviously, I find current international culture to be sorely lacking in this regard. Why is it that our politicians and media cannot simply point out that the United Nations is a farce and should be reorganized as it has become a tool for third world, largely Islamofascist governments to concentrate most of their resolutions on Israel and not address any illegal acts by any Arab countries, any NGOs or any terror organizations. Giving Kofi Annan a Nobel Prize does not transform something that is Evil into something that is Good. Annan was the UN official who refused Canadian General Romeo Dallaire, commanding the UN force in Rwanda, another 3000 troops that Dallaire said could prevent the Rwandan genocide. In a moral world those who assist in genocide should be put on trial, not given Nobel prizes. Not only do Palestinians send their children to die, but they celebrate their death as long as they have killed lots of Jews in a suicide bombing. Not only did Palestinians attack the Israeli sports team at the Munich Olympics, but those terrorists who survived, were welcomed as heroes by Gaddafi’s Libya. Fabrication of events are common - from the supposed Jenin massacre to the al-Dura staged and false murder. There have been staged funerals where the supposed deceased gets up and walks away. There is the denial of unequivocal historical and archeological evidence of Jews living in Israel centuries before there was such a thing as a Palestinian people. Liars, lovers of death, abusers of women, haters of liberty, these are a people who reject everything beautiful in this life and instead embrace a culture of death, that prevents their own people from moving forward by adopting a blamology focused on Jews. A country that embraces life, beauty, Justice, medical and scientific advances is shunned. Yasr Arafat who was driven out of Jordan was nevertheless made into a saint by Bill Clinton and the American media. Fortunately, my country, Canada, is one of the few countries in the world where mainstream politicians are unafraid to stand up proudly for what is right (even though the media and the universities are as hostile to Israel as in many European countries). The Government’s House Leader, John Baird, and an opposition Liberal MP, Joe Volpe, both recently spoke at a Carleton University event, which was a bipartisan response to perennial Israeli Apartheid Week demonstrations. “Israel’s values are Canada's values,” Volpe said, and his statement was supported by Baird when he added that slurring Israel with an apartheid label “is really an attack on Canadian society and Canadian values.” Volpe called the smear campaign “offensive” and identified it as an attempt to foreclose debate by intimidating those with opposing views, while Baird called this misapplication of “apartheid” an abuse of free speech with no basis in reality and delegitimizing Israel its only goal. Can one imagine Barack Obama making such statements? People who place rockets and other military installations in the middle of, or close to, civilian residences are evil people. When they use those rockets hundreds of times against civilians they must expect that a democratic nation protecting its people must try to knock out those rockets. They must expect that even a country like Israel, that takes extraordinary measures to avoid civilian casualties, will end up killing some civilians. Anyone who is offended by that should speak out against Hamas and Hezbollah placing their rockets and other military hardware in such places. Instead, such papers as the New York Times reserve their indignation for the liberal democratic country. Even worse, they tend not to show photos of intentionally murdered Israeli civilians like the Fogel family from Itamar, but assist in Palestinian propaganda by well publicizing the images of dead Palestinians. I believe that a high school student knows that this is wrong and I also believe that by the time that high school student finishes a university journalism program he has been convinced that it is right. Wrong has been made into right. We should especially be concerned about what is being taught to Education students and Journalism students. When Good is banished from our schools and our media and when fewer and fewer people are attending church and synagogue and getting the traditional Judeo-Christian ethic there, we have a major problem. It does not seem that difficult to me to know what are Good values. But in an education system that pretends to be “value-free”, a whole generation of people will have a harder time. To me, these are good values:
- fundamental constitutional freedoms such as freedom of speech, religion, assembly
- equal treatment for women
- taking responsibility for your actions and not blaming others
- not killing or injuring others except in self defence
- not bearing false witness
Read next: Western Civilization in Peril--Coming to a Head
Email Us | Reader Friendly | Comments
Howard Rotberg is a Canadian author and publisher. He is the author of <em>The Second Catastrophe: A Novel about a Book and its Author and Exploring Vancouverism: The Political Culture of Canada’s Lotus Land. His latest book, Tolerism: The Ideology Revealed, about the overemphasis on being tolerant as opposed to upholding liberal freedoms, individual human rights and justice. He has written for Frontpage Magazine, Pajamas Media, Scragged.com, the Vancouver Sun, the Waterloo Region Record, Freedom Press Canada Journal, and Canada Free Press and is the founding publisher of Mantua Books.</em>
