The mis-use of words in the war against the Jews
Occupied territories, suicide bombers, cycle of violence, hard-line, moderate, peace process, peace, terrorists, martyrs, freedom fighters, national liberation movements, activists
Patrick Martin, in Canada’s Globe & Mail described the Palestinian Authority as “moderate and secular”
Even journalists at the supposedly better newspapers are unashamed to use the most inappropriate and conclusive words to reflect their unexamined conclusions rather than report on the facts, or in the case of opinion pieces, marshal the facts used to reach their conclusion. On Saturday, May 29, 2011, for example, Patrick Martin, in Canada’s Globe & Mail described the Palestinian Authority as “moderate and secular”; and a front page story in the Washington Post described Israeli Prime Minister Benyamin Netanyahu as “hawkish”. Neither article provided any proof that these terms were appropriate; apparently the writers feel that these terms, although objectionable to me, are self-evident to their more liberal readership. Martin’s article dealt with the “unity pact” between the PA, which he deems “secular and moderate” and Hamas, which his article shows has a Charter that advocates genocide and destruction of Israel. As the writer of two books and numerous articles on the situation in Israel, I am certain that the plain meanings of “moderate” and “secular” do not apply at all to the Palestinian Authority, unless, as in the case of Mr. Martin, one’s moral compass has long left its Canadian roots and has adopted the cultural relativism and moral equivalency which is eating away at the foundations of a Western civilization, especially in Europe.The PA is NOT moderate:
- It has terrorist associates who operate under the names Fatah and Al-Aqsa Martyrs’ Brigade.
- Its leaders make one speech in English for western consumption and a very different speech in Arabic to reassure its own people that it will never give up the right to destroy Israel as a Jewish state by overwhelming it with millions of the descendants of so-called refugees (equal in number to the Jewish refugees from Arab lands that Israel long ago resettled in Israel).
- Abbas is a Holocaust denier
- Abbas has said that a future Palestinian state will not allow any Jewish citizens, whereas Israel has always allowed Arab citizens. The PA will not concede that Israel is a Jewish state the same way that all the surrounding countries are Muslim states
- It did not give up power and hold elections at the end of its term of office
- The PA names streets and public squares in honour of suicide bombers.
- Its school textbooks and state controlled media are anti-Semitic and make no mention of Israel, instead showing “Palestine” as extending right to the Mediterranean.
The PA is NOT secular:
- Only in the liberal democracies of the West is there a division between Church (or Mosque) and state.
- The PA’s ideology that it will not give up its rights to eventually settle millions of Arabs in all of Israel is based on the religious ideology of Islamism. So too does the support for the Palestinians in other Muslim countries stem from Islamist notions of Dar Al Islam – once a country has been ruled by Muslims, it must never be ruled by anyone else.
How did we lose the battle for words?
How did we lose the battle for words? Probably, because most of us didn’t even realize that the meanings of some very important words were gradually and subtly being taken from us, being changed from what we always thought they meant. We have been sitting idly and passively by, as our enemies have redefined key words, to make them what they want them to mean. Some very important words have been hijacked from us by people who think that if they “dress up” their immoral positions by adopting moral-type words, then all will be fooled as to what they are really intending. Israel “Apartheid” Week is just one example. The Nazis put up a large sign over the entrance to the Auschwitz concentration camp, stating “Arbeit macht frei” – “work shall make you free”. Of course, many of those who entered the camp were marked for extermination, not work; and those who were to be slave laborers would never gain their freedom through their work. Totalitarians are fond of repeating nonsensical slogans, in the belief that if repeated often enough they will be seen as true. Sometimes democrats do the same, of course (case in point – America’s term, Operation Enduring Freedom), but the nature of liberal democracy, with its system of opposition parties, free media, and free academics, is that there is, or should be, a constant debate over the use of any slogan. If newspapers are limiting that debate, what does that tell us about them? It seems that more latitude is given to propagandists on the “left” of the political spectrum than on the “right” of the political spectrum? For example, why can “peace activists” of the left make common cause with Hezbollah, and still be called peace activists? By the same logic, a proponent of U.S. military action for the purpose of eventually creating peace could also claim to be a “peace activist”. My point is that those of the “left” who whitewash violence against the West are given too much latitude by media and academics. Moreover, why should certain parties be able to claim that they are on the “left” or that they represent the progressive side? I think that I am a progressive, because, in my view, “progress” demands that backwards, theocratic, anti-liberal regimes should make progress towards modern freedoms, technology and separation of church (et al.) and state. That would be real progress. And yet certain labour unions, church groups, and academics insist that only they can be seen as progressive; it boggles the mind. In essence, what we are talking about is the sophisticated use of words as propaganda. By subtly changing the accepted use of a word or term, the propagandist effectively disinforms. And by the media allowing unexamined use of works like “moderate” and “hawkish” the media become organs of propaganda.Read next: Brad Lander pleading with his Muslim allies to let him stay at anti-Hindu hate rally
Email Us | Reader Friendly | Comments
Howard Rotberg is a Canadian author and publisher. He is the author of <em>The Second Catastrophe: A Novel about a Book and its Author and Exploring Vancouverism: The Political Culture of Canada’s Lotus Land. His latest book, Tolerism: The Ideology Revealed, about the overemphasis on being tolerant as opposed to upholding liberal freedoms, individual human rights and justice. He has written for Frontpage Magazine, Pajamas Media, Scragged.com, the Vancouver Sun, the Waterloo Region Record, Freedom Press Canada Journal, and Canada Free Press and is the founding publisher of Mantua Books.</em>
