Talking to Taliban is Pointless and an Act of Surrender
Barack Obama 'naïve and irresponsible'
During his electoral campaign in 2008, Barack Obama said repeatedly that if he was elected president of the United States of America, he would talk to the Taliban.
At the time, Obama’s rival, Ms. Hillary Clinton described Obama’s wish as “naïve and irresponsible”.
Now she is Obama’s Secretary of State and has to obey her boss.
But is it really possible to appease the Taliban?
First of all, the Taliban is a heterogeneous group of radical Muslims. Each group has got its own warlord, and rules a state within a state. But all of them want to impose the Shari’a law, a stone-age law, which is anti-women, against modernity, and anti-non-Muslims.
The Taliban finances its local “empires” and weapons through drugs, force Afghans to pay Zakat (a kind of taxes), and blackmail development projects through “protection money”.
Muhsen, an Afghan engineer (who does not want to be identified by his last name) and who works for the GTZ (a German development organization), told me during his last trip to Germany, where his parents live under an asylum status:
Afghanistan is still in ruins after 20 years of war and destruction. In order for us to work on the project, a water plant for Kandahar, the GTZ pays protection money to the local Taliban war-lord, Abdulqader Mohammadi. We have never seen the man. He monthly sends his men to cash the money, about $ 20,000 a month. For working 12 hours a day, I get only $ 5,000 a month. In addition, Mohammadi forces workers in the project to pay him $2 from the $5 each of them earns a day from hard work under tough conditions.
Thus far, the Taliban has violated all agreement reached with the NATO forces in Afghanistan. The latest was with the British. After promising not to attack a girls' school in southern Afghanistan, the Taliban did assault the school and killed 12 students and three English language teachers.
In 2007, an inmate in Guantanamo with number 008 and called Abdulrasul was released. Back in southern Afghanistan, he rejoined the Talibans and is coordinating insurgence against the Afghan army, police, and Western forces.
The Taliban has no interest whatsoever in negotiating with the West and to live in peace. A peace agreement would mean an end to them and the flow of money.
A young German soldier with the German troops in Afghanistan and neighbor of mine told me over a short visit to his parents here in Germany, “The Taliban are not only terrorizing their own people, they are also terrorizing the armed allied troops. We (3,500 German soldiers) are scared. We dare not leave our camps when we are off duty. When we come back safe from protecting construction works, we utter a sigh of relief and thank God we are still alive. The foreign troops in Afghanistan are not acting they are rather re-acting. We need more troops. But who listens?”
Most of Afghanistan experts assert that Afghanistan is ruled by a motley alliance of former warlords, former Mujahedeens, old communists, and royalists. Hamid Karzai, the President of Afghanistan, called the great “accommodator” by Western observers, is tolerated as long as he does not jeopardize the interests of members of this alliance. Karzai hardly has any power. He is only able to leave his compound by helicopter.
The alliance comprises:
- Former warlord and Karzai’s current chief of staff General Dostam.
- Ex-Governor Ismail Khan, known as the “Lion of Herat” during the anti-Soviet resistance and is currently the Minister of Energy.
- Former Minister of Defense and former head of the Northern Alliance’ secret service Marshal Fahim.
- Retired General Olumi who was the infamous Najibullah’s chief in Kandahar.
- Yunus Qanuni, currently Speaker of Parliament and a former Mujahedeen member.
- Sayed Mohammad Gulabzoy, a former communist lieutenant who toppled the regime of Daud in 1978.
- Prince Mustafa, the grandson of King Mohammad Zahir.
- Burahanuddin Rabbani, the President of Afghanistan under the Mujahedeen and Taliban, who is a radical Islamist and opponent of democracy.
Read next: Extend the Miracle or Surrender to Darkness
Email Us | Reader Friendly | Comments
Guest Column——Bio and Archives
Items of notes and interest from the web.
